Following criticism of some of the penalties served to drivers during the Japanese Grand Prix Formula One Management has published a montage of footage showing new angles of the incidents.
Most of the angles were not shown to fans who saw the standard F1 television footage as provided to ITV and many other stations during the race.
I’ve had a look at the videos and it’s given me some new thoughts on the incidents. Have a look for yourself and post your comments below.
Hamilton and Raikkonen
I’d seen the first two shots before. The third, slightly higher angle makes it very clear that it was Heikki Kovalainen, not Lewis Hamilton, that put Kimi Raikkonen off the circuit.
Watching the onboard from Hamilton made me realise he hadn’t actually out-braked himself by as much as I originally thought he had – he did go off the circuit, but not as far as I first thought.
This made me realise Raikkonen must have braked a bit late for the corner as well – though not as late as Hamilton – or surely Hamilton would have shot past him and Raikkonen would have been able to turn into the corner, as we’ve seen happen many times before (think Massa and Hamilton at Sepang last year).
Read more about this incident: Hamilton and Raikkonen’s Fuji clash – the penalty they got wrong (Video)
Massa and Hamilton
Not much new here – Mass clearly hit Hamilton and deserved a penalty. But the onboard camera from Massa gives me the impression it was not an intentional take-out, as some people have suggested, just a bad misjudgement by Massa.
Read more about this incident: Massa and Hamilton’s Fuji crash – the penalty they got right (Video)
Bourdais and Massa
I wrote before that I didn’t think the external camera angle made it possible to say will total certainty that Bourdais was innocent. Unfortunately none of the new angles help answer that either. For me the key question is: was Bourdais right up against the inside of the corner when the two touched?
However it seems clear to me there was more Massa could have done to avoid the incident. He has space to his left to use to avoid Bourdais, Bourdais had very little space to his right, if any at all.
I think the stewards should have stayed out of this one – it was a racing incident. By getting involved, they will find themselves expected to uphold this dubious precedent in the future. And the same goes for the Hamilton/Raikkonen incident.
Read more about this incident: Bourdais gets 25s penalty
Still, it’s good to see F1.com making worthwhile use of their enormous media resources. Here’s a few more suggestions for them.
A similar thing happened after last year’s Fuji race when the incident between Mark Webber and Sebastian Vettel was re-investigated after new footage emerged on the Internet that had been shot by a fan.
Have these new videos changed your interpretation of the three penalties handed out at Fuji this year?
Comments have been split across multiple pages. If you are having difficulty viewing the pages, click here to see all comments.