One question that people who don’t follow motor racing often ask is "how fit are the drivers?" If F1’s not your thing, it’s easy to assume racinga Formula 1 car is no more strenuous than driving on the road.
Toyota team doctor Ricardo Ceccarelli gives some extraordinary insight into the punishing forces an F1 driver is subject to – and how fit they need to be
There is no other sport in the world which compares to the demands Formula 1 puts on the heart.
The heart rate of a top driver can average over 180bpm for a race distance of 90 minutes or more. This is huge and no other sport keeps a heart rate so high for such a long time.
On top of that there is a lot of muscle work for the whole body – heavy work for neck muscles to cope with the G forces, high loads on legs and arms and good lumbar strength to stabilise the body. A normal person could do two or three laps in a Formula 1 car under those stresses before physically they couldn’t continue.
What I often think makes F1 different from many other sports is the demands it places on a drivers’ concentration. In football, for example, a player is always paying attention to what is going on and often moving around – but his activity on the ball is occasional.
In F1 the driver is working all the time and the slightest misjudgement on the controls can cause a crash or a spin. Ceccarelli explains:
The demand on the muscles is important but the load on the brain is amazing. Formula 1 is a sport where the brain has to be working hard for the whole race.
In tennis you have a break every few seconds, in boxing you break every three minutes, in shooting you break all the time. This means a Formula 1 driver’s brain is working in a different way. When you compare a Formula 1 driver’s brain to an average person, the way it works is completely different.
When a driver is racing he is driving differently to a qualifying lap, which puts more intense physical strain on him. In qualifying a driver is right on the limit, always very close to a mistake and his heart can be beating 50bpm faster than a normal racing lap. This shows the body is doing a massive amount of work, which is possible to sustain for a few minutes but not a whole race.
At Sepang two weeks ago we saw Fernando Alonso compete despite suffering an ear infection. What kind of effect might that have had on his performance?
The affect [of illness] on the driver is really subtle and difficult to see.
Before I worked with Toyota, I saw a driver who was starting the race after having a very bad infection for four days. He lost a lot of fluids and he arrived on Sunday feeling really bad, but he had to start. He told me after the race that he felt he could collapse at any point but he finished in the top six because he had a good car.
When a driver who is normally super fit is sick, he is likely to be four tenths – maximum half a second – slower than usual in the race.
trocadero
21st April 2009, 20:37
Jenson Button’s performance in several triathalon events and Mark Webber’s Tasmania Challenge tell you how fit these guys are.
Keith Collantine (@keithcollantine)
21st April 2009, 23:10
And Trulli’s done a few marathons hasn’t he?
Fred Schechter
21st April 2009, 20:46
I love this topic. Too often I hear “Forumula one isn’t a sport, they’re just sitting in a car”.
I think the best example I can relate to these people is this:
Play the board game operation while running 5:15 minute miles (that’d be a distance of over 17 miles in 90 minutes)on a treadmill while the treadmill is attached to a rollercoaster for 90 minutes straight.
That ought to generate the right amount of stress on the human body to simulate an F1 race. Oh yeah, and you better win at Operation every time (or you crash). Have fun avoiding vomiting and passing out!
Anyone that isn’t astounded by F1 fitness, is simply not a fan.
ref: the game operation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_(game)
Terry Fabulous
21st April 2009, 22:02
Great example Fred, I will use this with my unenlightened work colleagues.
I reckon I am pretty fit and can do a half marathon in about 85 minutes. ‘Old man’ Trulli did one a year or so again and he would have been 1500m in front of me by the end!! Fit!!!
Keith Collantine (@keithcollantine)
21st April 2009, 23:09
Amazingly there isn’t a video of someone doing that on Youtube already…
Gman
21st April 2009, 20:57
It’s hard to imagine a sport that requires more fitness than F1- I have often compared it more to flying jet aircraft than to other sports when taking about the stresses it places on the body.
Kherubim
22nd April 2009, 3:24
More specifically, flying modern jet fighters like F-16s and Typhoons…
I remember reading something about the ground effect cars of the 70s and how much G-load they inflicted on the drivers.
If cornering speeds and turn rates continued to increase (from those days, assuming that ground effects was allowed), we’d either see drivers G-LOC in the corners or drivers wearing G-suits.
Jonatas
21st April 2009, 21:10
It’s almost a shame Nasa doesn’t recruit these guys for space travel after they retire. Guys like Alonso, Schumacher and a few others certainly aren’t strangers to enegineering.
Williams 4ever
21st April 2009, 22:20
Add Vettel to that mix, While he was instrumental in his 1st win in Monza by his thorough recon of every inch of the race track in Friday FP’s, his car setup was the one that even Computer aided Biggies at Ferrari and Macca couldn’t simulate. Latest team news of RBR has also indicated that his current team-mate has started copying his setup coz its simply too fast.
And of course don’t forget to add my favorite Professor to that list. Not to mention JPM who contributed to improvisation of Rear Suspension design of Adrian Newey at Macca. Given that Bigger team like Macca will not change unless its not there in Computers(sometime computers of other teams)
So there are some drivers out there, whom you need to respect not only for “Brawn” but for “Brains” as well.
pk
22nd April 2009, 10:05
maybe, but their personalities wouldn’t be the best fit. while they may be on teams, they are not exactly “team players”. their paranoia about being the best wouldn’t exactly make them easy to get along with in a confined capsule for weeks at a time.
tifosi4eva
21st April 2009, 21:40
I think F1 drivers are probably the fittest sportsmen ever. This reminds me of when Richard Hammond tried to drive an F1 car and he was full throttle for all of 0.2 seconds, and the tyres went cold off him driving slow!
Its amazing to think the physical strain on the body when driving these cars, all of that and they are still expected to overtake and push to the limit all the time!
Arthur954
21st April 2009, 22:32
It seems that the absolutely top drivers can handle these great stresses in an automatical way, and at the same time their mind is detached from these bodily hardships and thinking several laps ahead in terms of strategy and finding flaws in the drivers ahead.
Ours is a tremendous sport. Even us armchair enthusiasts have to hold on real hard to the chair and to the vodka with Red Bull
Hugo Bourgeois
21st April 2009, 21:55
Lovely feature! Coincidence is that I was just using this theme to my parents today, who argued that F1 is not a real sport “like athletics, for instance”… I mailed them this article :-)
Keith Collantine (@keithcollantine)
21st April 2009, 23:07
If I had a penny for every time I’ve had that argument…
tifosi4eva
22nd April 2009, 12:13
I know what you mean, it annoys the life out of me! You just feel like saying, well you drive one, see how far you get.
sas
21st April 2009, 21:57
another question i would like to ask, i suspect now an f1 driver cannot smoke now, however what happpens if he did what would be the effect?
Number 38
21st April 2009, 21:59
FIVE LAPS in my go-kart and your neck will know it!
After a 200 lap day there’s plenty of bruises on your back
and sides. I can’t drive an F1 car but isn’t it interesting how many F1 drivers also race karts?
mkh1
21st April 2009, 22:38
Your right with that statement. I did some karting for the first time a few weeks ago and my body was acheing like hell after that.
I knew top level motorsport required a super human level fitness before but after realising how physical karting was I’m just in awe in their fitness.
Loki
21st April 2009, 23:56
A standard 30min session in a bog standard go-kart (dunno which one you have Number 38, sounds a beast) knackers THE HELL out of me. After about 15-20mins my arms are gone and I’m fighting my body more than the clock. I also notice I’m not breathing properly – not quite out of breath, but a similar type of exhaustion.
I also drove a Rally car in 3 x 10minute sessions – those 10 minutes are gruelling (though in a much different way), there was a point when I thought “I. don’t. think. I. can. manage. another. gear. . . . change!”
Damon
21st April 2009, 22:04
Cycling?? Cyclists sometimes make 260km cycling for not 90min, but over 5 hours straight [sic!], averaging speeds of over 50km/h on a bicycle.
Sush Meerkat
21st April 2009, 22:39
most F1 drivers are cyclists.
Lewis
22nd April 2009, 11:02
Cycling has the physical endurance part, but nowhere near the G tolerance or the concentration requirement – unless on a very fast, tight Alpine descent or similar, where a wrong move may result in a big fall – but these only last for a few minutes.
jay
21st April 2009, 22:11
Every time someone tells me that racing is a pansy sport, I remind them of Ernest Hemingway (which I’m sure has been shared here before but I’ll share it anyway)
“There are only three sports: bullfighting, motor racing, and mountaineering; all the rest are merely games.”
:)
Arthur954
21st April 2009, 22:23
He forgot about bowling
Loki
21st April 2009, 23:49
Next time you hear that tell them at least it’s not a bunch of guys falling over crying mommy everytime another foot goes near them.
Good quote btw!
Mussolini's Pet Cat
21st April 2009, 23:12
None of ’em are as fit as Kylie Minogue
ajokay
22nd April 2009, 8:43
I prefer Danni
Lewis
22nd April 2009, 11:04
So did Jenson.
(Allegedly).
Pink Peril
22nd April 2009, 11:30
Nah, that was Black Jack
Melanie
22nd April 2009, 2:23
F1 drivers are not engineers, even Alonso and Schumacher.
Kherubim
22nd April 2009, 3:28
Although some have engineering diplomas… like Mansell… And didn’t Nico Rosberg give up his engineering course at the Imperial College for GP2?
Jay Menon
22nd April 2009, 3:42
Yeah Nico was accepted to read Engineering at Imperial, at thats pretty impressive. You need pretty damn good scores to get into Imperial even if you’ve got the cash.
Agreed that F1 drivers aren’t engineers, but it helps if they’re technically inclined. The basic concept of engineering is all based on common sense, if you have an analytical mind, you can pick up on the aspects quickly.
I believe that the best drivers, past and present to be very intelligent people. The likes of Senna, Prost, Schumacher and Alonso have all been great in car development just as they were on track. Some drivers like Olivier Panis and Luca Badoer may not have had chequered racing careers, but their technical feedback from their test roles were regarded invaluable.
pSynrg
23rd April 2009, 0:00
Jay Menon:
I’d have to say engineering concepts were based more on the laws of physics. Applied with creative, lateral and fact based thinking, quite the opposite of common sense?
Or am I just stoned?
Jay Menon
23rd April 2009, 6:57
Psynrg:
Yeah, you’re right, its based on the laws of physics…but for me, if you really think about it, it’s all is common sense.
I’m not gloating or anything, but I hold a Master degree in Engineering, and work for one of the biggest players in the oil indusrty…and to me, throughout my studies and career…everything always boiled down to common sense.
Maybe I’ve been stoned all this while then eh?..hahaha
Jay Menon
22nd April 2009, 2:26
Can’t argue with Mussolini’s Pet Cat….Kylie is a different variation of fit perhaps?..haha..very nice nonetheless
I’ve tried to explain this to various people, they just don’t get it. My American collegues believe that American Football players are the fittest athletes in the World! Must be really fit to play a game that stops every 10 seconds I guess.
I’ve read about the fitness regimes these drivers go through, its scary! I remember Jacques Villeneuve used to run 15 miles a day and swim for a couple hours. These guys are different breed of human! I spent 30 minutes in a go kart and by the time I was done, I my arms felt like I’d been doing push ups for a year and I couldn’t feel my legs.
Forward this so as many doubters as you can!!
kingKUPA
22nd April 2009, 4:01
you cant compare f1 to American Football a football player may not make it thought a full race but an f1 driver woud not last 5min in a football game this is like saying a marathon runner could beat Muhammad Ali in a fight becaues he can run for 3 hours.
the conditioning level of an f1 driver is world class but it is Impossible you compare that to football you try running at a full sprint and being hit every 10secs by a 250lbs man that runs a 4.50 in the 40 yard dash im not saying that football is better just different
Jay Menon
22nd April 2009, 4:13
Nobody is comparing them based on the skill required to compete in their respective sports, its just about fitness, or endurance if you’d like.
An American football player is not as fit as an F1 driver.
kingKUPA
22nd April 2009, 4:24
this is an unfair comparison a football player is just as fit just in a different way there is more to being fit than just running
Matt
23rd April 2009, 8:38
An American football player? Ha! How much action is there in a game? Lets see them do something for 90 mins straight
sultryBOB
22nd April 2009, 3:27
f1 is very demanding but motocross i belive is just as demanding there are no Long Straights in motocross
m0tion
22nd April 2009, 4:14
Cam McConville a host for F1 in Australia and V8 driver did a segment on his recent Honda test in Japan that is worth a look. He was struggling by the end of the day and the V8 drivers all talk physical fitness and their training regimes these days.
Pink Peril
22nd April 2009, 11:34
A couple of years ago they put a heart rate monitor on Rick Kelly during one of the races. It was very interesting to see how high his heart rate got !
Matt
23rd April 2009, 9:00
I saw McConville driving the Honda, very interesting.
Didn’t David Coulthard sack a personal trainer once because the trainer wasn’t fit enough to keep up with him? Despite the trainer being a green beret or something similar…
Eduardo Colombi
22nd April 2009, 5:01
Just one exemple: Ayrton Senna and his extreme focus on the qualifying laps.
You must be strong not just fisicly but mentaly. You need just one lapse of concentration and boom! You’re out of the track. As Senna used to say i must push ’til your limite and go further. See the 91′ Interlagos GP and see how though is to drive a race car…
The Sri Lankan Senna
22nd April 2009, 6:20
Dont forget Moto Gp which is juat as exausting, i Do karting ( Kt100 senior unrestricted) and just to keep myselft from looking like an idiot i run 4 days a week for 30 mins + streangth training for neack, wrists forearms and back, just to deal with the levels of stress. and dont rule out the fact that the stress levels, both physically and mentaly rise if it rains dring an f1 race while just about every athlet in other forms of sports except for swimmers wrap it up. for those people that want to test the levels of a real F1 car i suggest heading over to europe and tying out AGS for a session in a modern grand prix car. im sure you all will agree f1 drivers are some of the fittest in the sports business
Rahzam
22nd April 2009, 6:37
Keith, Great article. I love this. I know drivers are fit but how demanding this sports is. wow!
Keith Collantine (@keithcollantine)
22nd April 2009, 8:34
The quotes were put out by Toyota the other day. Buried on a bookshelf somewhere I think I’ve got some similar research they did in the early ’80s, comparing Gilles Villeneuve and Didier Pironi in ground effects-era Ferraris. Will see if I can dig it out…
Achilles
22nd April 2009, 6:48
I think the perception of a lack of fitness is, maybe, the way that in an earlier era, motor racing driving was seen as glamorous and for wealthy playboys, often caught on film having a fag, and with a cocktail in hand. When interviewed the drivers would be very laconic about the dangers, and stresses, making it look so easy does’nt help, but very few mention the fact that these guys have to be that fit, strong, durable, and try to keep the weight down! Whilst still taking in enough nutrition to maintain that strength, bit of a science for many years, although I did hear that Mansell favoured Karate for his fitness training.
TeamOrders
22nd April 2009, 7:33
I’d suspect MotoGP is even more brutal on a body than F1. They have to be far more physical with there machine, clambering and pulling the bike side to side in turns fighting against teh gyroscopic effect and having no restraints or a backrest to ease against acceleration/braking forces.
….and then there’s the injuries.
Nah, F1 drivers are softies compared to the Stoners & Rossis :p
Keith Collantine (@keithcollantine)
22nd April 2009, 8:33
Aren’t Moto GP races quite short though?
pSynrg
23rd April 2009, 0:14
I think it’s two 45min races. I agree MotoGP riders are also supremely skilled with similar athletic capability, and a bit mental!
The most significant differences are the g-forces.
MotoGP pulls maximum 1.8g’s to F1’s 4.5g. Imagine weighing 4.5 times your weight and operating extremely sensitive machines at speeds that are always near or on the edge of what is possible.
A feat very difficult to maintain even in a decent computer sim (for the likes of me) for any length of time. F1 – It’s just all so …. controlled, powerful, violent and fast!
schumi the greatest
22nd April 2009, 8:12
i think this is a good example.
in november last year i did a single seater experience at rockingham. It lasted 10 minutes, i cant tell you how much my arms hurt from driving the car the only thing that got me through it was the adrenalin…now a formula 1 car has about 4 times more horspower so the strain on your arms and your body would be immense at the speeds they hit. imagine going through eau rougue..people like us couldnt do it because our body couldnt put up with the g-forces.
thats a good point about the concentration factor…i know thta schumacher always made sure he was super fit so he could spend as much time concentrating and making observations during the race.
Some people think f1 isnt really a sport where you need to be an “athlete” but there havent been many tubby drivers in the last 25 years has there??
Ben Auty
22nd April 2009, 8:34
Check out my article which is in the same vein as this one, a very interesting insight into just how fit these guys are, you will be surprised.
Ben Auty
22nd April 2009, 8:34
http://bleacherreport.com/articles/30864-formula-1-are-f1-drivers-considered-athletes/show_full
Loki
22nd April 2009, 11:03
I remember there was a reality TV show ages ago that had people fighting for the chance to become a race car driver (what cars in the end, I cannot remember, I think single seaters).
The very first round was a fitness test – basically, if you couldn’t do what they asked of you, you were eliminated. Just thinking back at the series of excercises, the last thing was a run – I can’t remember how long it was, it didn’t matter…if I had done everything they asked of me prior to that, I would’ve not been able to walk, nevermind run!
Fergus Gallas
22nd April 2009, 13:16
The F1 guys have all this demanding stress and in the meantime they also have delightful radio chat with gents like Briatore for the whole bloody 90 minutes.
Ronman
22nd April 2009, 14:15
I hate to admit that i thought driving a car around a track was relatively easy with respect to other sports. however about a year ago i was given the chance to drive a high performance super car around an F1 legal track, and after the instructor told me to go flat out but that we would be coming back in the pits after 3 laps. i said “3 laps!” common where’s the fun in that…. it’s my first take at a Lambo and 3 laps? he goes “believe me, it’s your first time after 3 laps of hard driving, you’d want to come in all by yourself. and he was right, after 3 laps, my hands were sweating, my back was wet (i think that the Qatar heat had something to do with it and the fact that i hit 290kph at the end of the straight on my second pass). in all cases after those 3 laps, i had a whole new understanding for race cars drivers and above all an unrivaled respect.
prior to that my only experience of track driving was on slow ass rental karts that i would stop driving because of the vibration and resultant itches. oh yeah and second regional spot in R/C racing
macca
22nd April 2009, 15:52
one of the best measurements of fitness is resting heart rate. i remember reading ukyo katayama had got his down to 36 bpm, which is pretty amazing but miguel indurain (multiple tour de france winner) had a waking heart rate of 29!
most of the nordic skiers aim for something in the low 30s.
i expect most of the current drivers rival this, they’re bodies take one hell of a beating – remember hamilton did last year’s malaysian gp without a water bottle; stuff like that reminds us just how incredible these humans are.
Fred Schechter
23rd April 2009, 18:10
Hammy went without water in Malaysia?! WOW, I can’t do without water for a silly 2 hour stint in a flogged miata, and that’s with a cool suit!
More than my fun analogy, I remember a great article (if anyone finds it I’d love to read it again) that detailed 2 doctors chatting between themselves. One grabbed an ekg trace for the race (90 mins of data, heart rate 200+ for most of it, I think it was a hot race) he shows it to his buddy who’s eyes bug out and says “What did this patient die from?!”
The other doctor cooly states, “He’s sitting right over there.” (points to an F1 driver sitting and reading a magazine).
As for American football comparisons, the training regimes and play patterns are far too different to compare. That is a sport I did grow up and and can properly vouch for their fitness at the highest levels. They are very extreme athletes who are very fit, but due to the play pattern allowing pauses and impacts being more instantaneous and strength based (rather than endurance) they design how their bodies are shaped to cope with the punishment in a wholly different way. I do however believe that some skills players (mostly quarterbacks) could likely have chosen the F1 route, their dexterity and memory are very highly tuned (you memorize 1000 play variations) but they would have needed to start from the beginning and focus on endurance (which they have not) oh yeah, and they’d all be too big to fit (they’re typically in the 6’5″ 250lb range nowadays)
F1Fan
23rd April 2009, 19:31
Alonso’s neck is built like an NFL player’s !
Zoltan
11th May 2009, 13:46
True, Hamilton did Malaysia last year without water coz his water bottle malfunction and he lost a lot of water, Also Alonso did Bahrain this year this a Water Bottle malfunction and after he finished the race, collapsed. He has lost 6.5kg of weight (liquid) compared to the normal 2-3 kg in a race. That is extreme!
Wehalle
26th August 2009, 8:01
Is their any other sport out there other than Formula1 that leaves a sportsman less 3-4KG after the event? With Formula1 races in hot climates such as Baharain and malaysia, Formula1 Drivers are left with 3-4Kgs less their body weight after the even due to dehydration.
Even after all this you have to be very fit at the end of the Formula1 racing event in order to be able to sit up in the podium and smile.
Vettel rules
29th August 2009, 22:48
I think f1 drivers are out of this world. They have to be so fit be able to cope with the stress and then race round the track at an astonishing pace:0
Vettel rules
29th August 2009, 22:52
When I drove a 40mph go kart my legs and arms were dead my back hurt and my neck was under a little bit of pain but imagine driving 200mph
Alex
4th December 2016, 1:41
it is rather sad the sport has turned that way. Graham Hill was 45 when he raced in the 70’s. This kids sport has lost its appeal as it has become more about fitness than skills and mental strength that are acquired through maturity like a horse jumping champion for example.
They are so much assisted by technology that is has become more about who is able to stand physical torture than anything else!