Why the Spanish GP was better in person than on TV

From the Stands

Posted on

| Written by

The Spanish Grand Prix received the lowest rating of the year from F1 Fanatic readers. But Madi Murphy was watching the race in the stands and found it hugely enjoyable.

‘Not one that had appealed to me’

The Spanish Grand Prix isn’t one that has ever hugely appealed to me, but after two of my friends went last year and raved about it, I decided to give it a chance. I’d been to F1 races before but this was my first time at the Circuit de Catalunya.

One of the best things about going to this race is its proximity to such a great city. We booked our trip last autumn, taking advantage of the ‘early bird’ discount for the race tickets along with inexpensive deals on flights and an apartment in the El Born district of Barcelona.

This was an ideal place to stay: we could walk to many of the city’s attractions and were close to the Passeig de Gracia train station. That allowed us to take a train to Montmelo and take a leisurely one-hour walk to the circuit, stopping along the way to buy coffee and croissants.

The circuits has some great general admission viewing areas and it’s easy to walk around to get different views of the track. For most of the weekend, however, we were happy to remain in our seats. We were in grandstand G, close to turns 12 and 13, from where we could see from the entrance to turn 10 to the DRS detection line before the final corner. We could also pick out a distant TV screen with a pair of binoculars to keep abreast of positions and lap times.

Sunburn and support races

We arrived early on Friday to make the most of our seats and enjoy the practice sessions. The circuit is easy to navigate and there are plenty of food stands, merchandise stalls and toilets around the track.

In terms of food, you are allowed to bring pretty much anything to the track (no glass, but drinks in plastic bottles are fine). We took full advantage by making ourselves packed lunches every day, so we didn’t need to frequent the predictably pricey food outlets. The only time we did succumb was when one friend bought a can of Fanta for a frankly extortionate ??3.50 (3).

We came well prepared with both raincoats and sunscreen, but the one thing we weren’t prepared for was how windy it was going to be. The unfortunate effect of the blustery weather that followed the rainy Friday morning was that we felt so cold we had no idea that we were getting sunburnt. On Saturday we noticed several other red-faced spectators who’d made the same mistake.

Qualifying was great fun, particularly witnessing the blisteringly fast laps by Rosberg and Hamilton. And then we were treated to a thrilling GP2 race, with Robin Frijns and Tom Dillmann putting in seriously impressive performances.

The support races on the Sunday morning weren’t quite up to the standard of that first GP2 race, but were still enjoyable. The GP3 season got off to a good start, and Porsche Supercup was enlivened by the crowd-pleasing presence of Sebastien Loeb.

FanVision, where art thou?

This was the first grand prix I’ve been to for a long time where we didn’t have FanVision as their F1 service was terminated before the season began. It was a shame as I am very shortsighted and have previously relied heavily on the FanVision timing screen during qualifying as I usually can’t read the list on the video walls (even with binoculars, this proved difficult).

We brought radios with us to hear trackside commentary but soon discovered that English-language commentary was only available for the F1 sessions. This was particularly frustrating during GP2 and GP3 qualifying, as the lap times are not listed on the screen, so we had no way of knowing the order until the end of the session. Even during the F1 race, the standard of commentary was pretty poor.

It was clear that we weren’t going to get much useful information, so we had to pay particularly close attention during a race in which most drivers made four pit stops. Many people who watched the race on TV suggested it was quite hard to follow, but I disagree. I’m not sure whether the TV direction or commentators are to blame, but from the grandstand it wasn’t too difficult to keep track of what was happening, even with all the pit stops.

The problem with not having commentary is that you miss out on some things. For example we had no idea what had happened to Sutil to put him so far back at the beginning of the race.

But the benefit of being able to see such a long section of the track, particularly a twisty stretch where the cars are not going flat out, is that it was simple to identify the drivers and note their differing speeds; the pace of the Ferraris and Raikkonen stood out massively at various points in the race. We were also lucky in that we could just see the start of the pitlane entrance from our seats, so we were able to spot when a driver was pitting.

Home-win fever

There were some great battles throughout the pack, which probably didn’t get as much coverage on TV as they deserved, such as the scrap for tenth between Ricciardo and Gutierrez, and the fight between Pic and Bottas. It was really exciting to see how the Caterham was able to chase down the Williams.

When we first got tickets for the race, I decided I wanted Alonso to win, purely because I wanted to experience the atmosphere of a driver winning his home race. I saw both of Nigel Mansell’s victories at Brands Hatch and Riccardo Patrese winning at Imola in 1990 but I was too young at the time to really appreciate either of them.

During the first lap, when Alonso made his killer start and got up to third place, the roar of the crowd was electric. And every time the Ferrari gained a place – especially from Sebastian Vettel – the crowd went wild. The atmosphere in the stands when he drove around with the Spanish flag after winning the race was fantastic.

However, the crowd soon quietened and many people left before the podium ceremony was even complete. Walking back through Montmelo, there was much less of a party vibe than I’d been expecting. I was slightly surprised by this – some of the races I’ve been to in recent years have such a fun, festival-style atmosphere that I can only imagine what it would be like for them to celebrate a home winner.

I’d been expecting the joy of Alonso’s victory to spill out from the circuit and be evident in the town and on the train, but it felt like it petered out very quickly. Had this been Mark Webber winning at Albert Park, the whole of Melbourne would have known about it!

‘Like watching a race in the eighties’

Although this was a bit anticlimactic I still thoroughly enjoyed my Spanish GP trip. It’s never been one of my favourite races to watch on television, but the combination of a fantastic view and an enthusiastic crowd made for a great experience. With the lack of commentary and my binoculars in hand, I sometimes felt it had more in common with the races my parents took me to in the eighties than the races I’ve attended in recent years.

And while this old-school approach didn’t have a detrimental effect on my enjoyment of the F1 race, I still feel that the practice/qualifying sessions and the support races would have been far easier to follow and appreciate had FanVision been available. It’s a real shame that the powers-that-be saw fit to deprive race fans of something so useful this season, without offering anything sufficient to replace it.

While it may not be a classic on the F1 calendar, I would definitely recommend the Spanish Grand Prix to other fans – not least because, with an extra day either side, you can combine the race trip with a holiday in a truly beautiful city. And, if the comments on the Rate the Race article are anything to go by, this was one grand prix that was far more enjoyable from the stands than on TV!

Have you been to the Spanish Grand Prix? Share your experiences of it here:

From the stands

Browse all From The Stands articles

Images © Madeleine Murphy

20 comments on “Why the Spanish GP was better in person than on TV”

  1. I enjoyed the Spanish Grand Prix from home, but in a way I imagine it would have more of the Football Crowd effect at the circuit itself – especially given the result.

    1. Me too, I wasn’t expecting the lowest result, I thought that was reserved for Malaysia, hopefully for the rest of the season.

    2. Personally I thought Malaysia was a decent enough race: the tyre conservation was still a bit excessive but honestly the battle of the bulls I found fantastic and Webber really wasn’t caught off guard!

      1. Pull your head in.

  2. The Blade Runner (@)
    31st May 2013, 11:57

    @keithcollantine I was there too for the second year running and thought it was fantastic! In fact I was shocked to hear some of the comments when I got home on the Monday.

    We were sat in stand J which was directly opposite the exit to the pits, had a great view of the main straight/DRS zone and had a huge video screen directly opposite so that you could follow the race. Interestingly we weren’t in the slightest bit confused by what was going on and who was where.

    For value for money you cannot beat Catalunya. We paid £120 for a 3 day ticket with superb views. We always go for an open stand and have so far been lucky with great weather on race day in each of the last 2 years. If you’re not careful you will go home with a red left leg and arm! Like you we stayed very cheaply in an ultra-modern apartment in a great area of Barca and we got to to see a little of the city.

    Total cost per person for GP ticket, flights and accommodation? £270

    Compare that cost to that of a basic 3 day ticket at Silverstone, Spa and others.

    You can’t beat experiencing F1 live, although I would caveat that by saying that you need to have a decent seat at the circuit. Catalunya is one of the best opportunities for Brits to experience F1 first-hand and have a decent dollop of glitz and sunshine thrown into the mix. Suffice to say that I’ve already booked for next year!

    1. The Blade Runner (@)
      31st May 2013, 14:25

      Sorry, my post should have been @ladym

  3. Thanks for the write up about this race Madeleine, sure enough the less than perfect race coverage took a lot of the good battles away from the cameras, and I would agree that the commentary did more to make me feel dubious about the race than to my enjoyment too.

    1. It’s FOM’s massive blind spot: regie and commentary really are important for your overall experience. Hopefully the next Bernie fixes this before anything else.

      1. Only the commentary I am taling about is a certain ex driver who most rate very highly @verstappen, not sure anyone at FOM is going to take that away.

        But in a broader sense – absolutely agree. Its the best reason for not watching F1 on Czech TV here, but through streaming. Because the commentators are in a studio and seem to have less knowledge, and less information available then I have with the internet, live blogs and timing apps, and they see only the same images. I am sure the same is true for far too many people in the world.

  4. I enjoyed Spanish GP, more than Monaco, and I´ve got the feeling that Canada will be superb!

  5.  @bascb I know certain TV commentators can be pretty annoying, but the trackside commentary at Barcelona was so bad I was desperate to have the Sky Sports team. At one point during free practice, Hamilton spun into the gravel, and it took the commentator about 3 minutes to confirm that it was Hamilton…. despite the fact that Rosberg was still going round the track and setting times. It was embarrassing.
    Oh, and then during the race he referred to ‘the Toro Rossos’ meaning Vettel and Webber…. anyone would think he’d never seen F1 before!

    1. Oh, I can fully understand what you mean. I remember being at Hockenheim in 2006 without a fanvision craving for information about what was going on outside of my view @ladym!

  6. Great article. On the Friday, were you able to move between the grandstands (roving ticket)?

    1. Technically we didn’t have a roving ticket, but there were no stewards on many of the grandstands and plenty of empty seats. We watched the GP3 qualifying from the grandstand at the back of the pit straight, and a couple of my friends watched the GP3 race on Saturday afternoon from that grandstand too (the stewards pretty much disappeared after F1 qualifying was over).

  7. with an extra day either side, you can combine the race trip with a holiday in a truly beautiful city.

    This is a really important point, and shows why circuits such as we have in korea will NEVER take off. Istanbul failed precisely for this reason. The vast majority of F1 fans dont have the luxury of travelling so far and at such expense purely to watch a race, for most of us it will become a holiday itself. Going to the middle of nowhere just has no appeal to anyone.

  8. I’m not sure whether the TV direction or commentators are to blame

    They are. THey are usually rubbish.

    Great article btw :)

    1. I think people are easily manipulated by how bad the tv crew is and influenced by the opinion of pundits.

    2. @fer-no65 Thanks :)

      I agree, the TV direction is often rubbish. I felt it reached a new low during the Monaco GP when Raikkonen overtook 6 cars in the last few laps and we were shown none of it.
      Also there was a period towards the end of the GP2 feature race in Monaco when Will Buxton was describing an on-track battle that we couldn’t see, and lamenting the fact that it wasn’t being shown as it was a great fight. And it was for 8th place and thus reverse-grid pole, so it’s not like it was irrelevant. I really don’t understand the logic of FOM’s TV direction, but it’s certainly not making any efforts to show the fans the best of the racing.

  9. Michael Brown (@)
    1st June 2013, 0:04

    I’m going to see the Canadian Grand Prix live, and it’s probably going to be very hot.

  10. I only watch the highlights packages as I find it impossible(apart from the lead bunch) to keep track of who is where. Pit stops after 4 laps, no live race position data on screen, most frustrating, definitely the worst motorsport coverage on Sky here in NZ

Comments are closed.