It’s often said that today’s Formula One cars are so similar that it would be hard to tell the difference between them if they were all painted the same colour.
It isn’t true, however. Each team approaches the rules its own way and a close look reveals their different solutions to the same challenges.
Get a better impression of how each team has tackled the rules this year using the interactive images below to compare all 11 of this year’s cars from four different angles.
Front
Ferrari has followed the trend for a short nose with a ‘thumb tip’ which many of its rivals including Red Bull and McLaren had already embraced. However pace-setters Mercedes continue to shun this approach in favour of a slimmer nose design, one which Renault has also adopted.
Go ad-free for just £1 per month
>> Find out more and sign up
Force India’s interpretation of the strict nose regulations has led them to a unique twin-vented solution. Manor, however, persists with a long nose which extends far beyond the front wing.
Rear
The most obvious change at the rear of the cars for 2016 is the revised exhaust arrangements. In an effort to increase the noise produced by the engines, teams must now separate the wastegate pipework from the main exhaust. With the exception of Renault, all the teams have added a pair of wastegate exhausts.
Here too Mercedes have a unique solution, clustering their three exhausts together, while the other nine teams with dual wastegate pipes have opted for an ‘inverted Mickey Mouse’ arrangement. Most of the teams ran small ‘monkey seat’ wings above the exhausts during testing with a few exceptions.
Side
Red Bull established the trend of running the car with a lot of rake in order to bring the nose closer to the ground and make the front wing work more effectively. This has been embraced by most of their rivals, notably McLaren, whose MP4-31 reveals the influence of ex-Red Bull man Peter Prodromou.
Higher cockpit sides are a common feature on all of this year’s cars. The FIA has raised the minimum height by 20mm and the driver’s head protection must now withstand a much more severe crash test in which it is subjected to a 50 Kilonewton force – up from 15kN last year.
Top
F1’s four different power units force designs to make different compromises when it comes to packaging. Last year McLaren trumpeted the ‘size zero’ policy they have pursued with Honda in an effort to shrink their rear bodywork and improve the car’s aerodynamics. Unfortunately whatever gains that offered were more than cancelled out by the engine’s poor performance and reliability.
This year other teams have moved towards the standard set by McLaren. The rear of the Ferrari is noticeably slimmer than last year and Red Bull has done an impressive job of shrink-wrapping their Tag Heuer-branded Renault.
The top-down view also sheds light on another of this year’s design trends at the front of the car: the S-Duct. Having tested it in Brazil last year Mercedes is one of the latest teams to adopt the vent which passes from underside the front nose and exits behind the driver’s number on the W07.
The field of 2016 analysed
Find out more about every car on this year’s grid:
- Mercedes W07: Technical analysis
- Ferrari SF16-H: Technical analysis
- Williams FW38: Technical analysis
- Red Bull RB12: Technical analysis
- Force India VJM09: Technical analysis
- Renault RS16: Technical analysis
- Toro Rosso STR11: Technical analysis
- Sauber C35: Technical analysis
- McLaren MP4-31: Technical analysis
- Manor MRT05: Technical analysis
- Haas VF-16: Technical analysis
The field of 2016 in pictures
More images and close-up photography of every 2016 car:
2016 F1 season
- Are tickets too dear? Crowds fell at some tracks in 2016
- F1’s TV audience decline stopped in 2016
- Brawn among key F1 hires announced by Liberty
- Has F1 hit ‘peak penalties’? Fewer sanctions in 2016
- Brundle reveals Monaco GP heart attack
gdewilde (@gdewilde)
7th March 2016, 12:57
Hands down the coolest feature ever on F1fanatic! Great!
mateuss (@mateuss)
7th March 2016, 19:09
Scrolled down and was about to comment the same thing. But not just coolest, the best.
It would be perfect if all the pictures could be matched perfectly, but close enough.
CARL FRYE
22nd December 2016, 13:05
The merc front image seems to be at a different angle than many of the others, as the rear wing is consistently much lower. However in the rear image it is mostly level with the others.
MacLeod (@macleod)
8th March 2016, 7:52
I think all site would have this feature even F1.com it self. Well done Keith!
Stubborn Swiss (@stubbornswiss)
7th March 2016, 13:00
Yup. You beat me to this comment.
Great feature, Keith!
Maciek (@maciek)
7th March 2016, 13:02
These are great! Thanks Keith!
markthornton90 (@markthornton90)
7th March 2016, 13:13
Brilliant new feature, thanks!
sato113 (@sato113)
7th March 2016, 13:25
nice. but typo-
‘Ferrari has followed the trend for a short nose with a ‘thumb tip’ which many of its rivals including Red Bull and Mercedes had already embraced. However pace-setters Mercedes continue to shun this approach’
mercedes never embraced the thumb nose. maybe you mean mclaren. @keithcollantine
Keith Collantine (@keithcollantine)
7th March 2016, 13:40
@sato113 Changed it, thanks.
sato113 (@sato113)
7th March 2016, 14:53
@keithcollantine it’s still wrong! Ferrari have a thumb nose, fine. And red bull have embraced it, fine. But mercedes have never embraced or had a thumb nose! they have shunned it. Merc and renault have slim, normal noses.
Basically swap mclaren and mercedes around.
Thedonz
7th March 2016, 16:21
Nah, leave it, it’s nice to think mclaren are the pace setters :)
sato113 (@sato113)
7th March 2016, 17:58
ha, i think keith is drunk ;)
Loup Garou (@loup-garou)
7th March 2016, 18:21
McLaren were the slow pace setters in 2015
KonPatTsh
7th March 2016, 13:27
Awesome.!! Thanks to be so innovative Keith
petebaldwin (@)
7th March 2016, 13:30
Awesome – great work @keithcollantine
FJBH10 (@fjbh10)
7th March 2016, 13:36
The Renault has no ‘Monkey Seat’ Winglet? I wonder why.
Trayambak Chakravarty (@major-dev)
7th March 2016, 14:29
Even Ferrari doesn’t
NewVerstappenFan (@jureo)
7th March 2016, 14:34
Barcelona does not need huge rear downforce…
Dev
7th March 2016, 13:43
Amazing!! Thanks Keith!!
Markellos Orfanos (@m4rk)
7th March 2016, 14:00
Well, everyone said it already, but I couldn’t resist…brilliant and thoughtful work Keith and everyone else who might have helped! Thanks!
Markellos Orfanos (@m4rk)
7th March 2016, 18:16
Playing around with the sliders, I came across a possible future feature you might consider. Adding a slider to adjust the opacity/transparency of each image. I tried it a bit in chrome to directly see the two images and understand the camera angle of each picture.
Todfod (@todfod)
7th March 2016, 14:00
I think he meant Williams
Todfod (@todfod)
7th March 2016, 14:01
How did this comment get here :P
Robbie (@robbie)
7th March 2016, 14:01
Very cool, @keithcollantine
NewVerstappenFan (@jureo)
7th March 2016, 14:32
Amazing webpage design. Good feature.
It is also amazing to see how similar F1 cars are in their design… Pretty much if they removed team liveries.. No way to tell quite a few.
MrBoerns (@mrboerns)
7th March 2016, 14:46
So What exactly Is that “size-zero” McLaren all about? Seems like an awful lot of trouble to go through only to have about the same size bodywork as everyone Else of you ask me
Alex J
7th March 2016, 15:32
Comparing the McLaren against the other top teams in the view from behind is pretty mind-blowing
sm
7th March 2016, 16:03
Well looks like they made it too small last year
spafrancorchamps
7th March 2016, 20:21
The Mercedes is much smaller from the back.
Keisalex
7th March 2016, 15:07
Dat top of the RB12… magnifique!!
Todfod (@todfod)
7th March 2016, 15:37
I could spend all day comparing these cars to each other. My first impressions while comparing Merc, Ferrari, Mclaren and Red Bull –
The Mercedes engine cover is far bulkier than the three other cars, but have built their sidepods and overall chassis seems lower and broader.
When it comes to rear end packaging, the red Bull is still the class of the field. Even Honda with their ‘size zero’ packaging cannot match Red Bull in that department.
The Ferrari and Mclaren chassis look very similar.
Mercedes air inlet above the driver’s head just looks plain and simple awesome.
Kingshark (@kingshark)
7th March 2016, 18:56
@todfod
Are you sure? Mercedes looks like they have by far the tightest rear end to me
Todfod (@todfod)
8th March 2016, 3:32
@kingshark
Check out the rear angle. Mercedes vs Mclaren. The engine cover seems to take a much larger surface area (volume of the engine pyramid) as compared to Mclaren who have a really slim top part of the triangle (from the air box)
Tim M (@tim-m)
7th March 2016, 15:40
Really, really cool Keith! This is fantastic.
Just an idea – At the end of the season, I’d be interested in being able to do the comparisons with the year end cars with these iterations to see how much they change over a season.
Bullfrog (@bullfrog)
7th March 2016, 15:56
Particularly like the back views – never been able to compare those before and they’re all different shapes and sizes.
The Merc’s an amazing piece of work, really tight and refined all over. But the best looking car of all from the side is the Manorosso…
digitalrurouni
7th March 2016, 16:03
Stunning work @keithcollantine!
Mizf1
7th March 2016, 16:09
Cool feature
WilliamB (@william-brierty)
7th March 2016, 16:10
I reeeeeeally, reeeeeeeeeeeeeally love this site…
F1 performance (@patent)
7th March 2016, 16:19
Awesome, brilliant, cool, super.
bravo and thanks Keith Collantine (@keithcollantine).
Lauri (@f1lauri)
7th March 2016, 16:29
Great job!
Illusive (@illusive)
7th March 2016, 16:36
The Ferrari McLaren pic is awesome, its like 2face.
PorscheF1 (@xtwl)
7th March 2016, 16:40
Unbelievable how sharp the Mercedes nose is compared to the bulky Ferrari one.
Christopher M
7th March 2016, 17:06
That has gotta be the coolest comparison feature for an F1 junkie, EVER. Thanks Keith! One thing I noticed is that the appendage on the Ferrari nose seems to be lower than most other cars. (yes, insert joke here) But, I would have thought that height was regulated and keeping it as high as possible for air flow would be preferable. Or is it just the camera angle and that is playing tricks on my viewpoint? The Merc style nose seems to block more air than most and they are the team to beat. Final thought, the aero on the Torro Rosso looks very advanced. Minardi has come a looong way in the last decade. :)
FlyingLobster27
7th March 2016, 17:26
This feature is absolutely brilliant. With all these Barcelona pictures from reasonably similar angles, it’s a joy. We mentioned the new F1 cars at lunch with a friend on Saturday, he’s going to love this!
Joao (@johnmilk)
7th March 2016, 17:52
I like to imagine Newey browsing F1Fanatic and comparing the RB with everynthing else.
Come on Adrian we know you are among us. Say something!!
woogle
7th March 2016, 18:44
best feature iv seen on here
maxxsilver
7th March 2016, 19:53
Things like this are the reason I come back here so many times in a day. Great stuff Keith!
barkun (@barkun)
7th March 2016, 21:26
brilliant feature !
Dan
7th March 2016, 21:39
That’s very clever!!
Douglas
7th March 2016, 21:51
Brilliant work!
Thanks for the effort
mantresx (@mantresx)
7th March 2016, 23:05
Hats off Keith very nice feature, hard to find websites mantained with this much dedication (F1 related or not), keep it up.
SauberS1 (@saubers1)
7th March 2016, 23:25
This is amazing! Very thanks!
Rick Lopez (@viscountviktor)
7th March 2016, 23:52
Surprised by how bulky the rear bodywork of the Williams is, even compared to Manor, needs a lot of work.
Great feature Keith, again shows how this site is the best F1 site on the web.
reh1v2.0 (@reh1v2-0)
8th March 2016, 0:11
An excellent idea and well executed! Thanks!
Mike
8th March 2016, 0:39
Really goes to show how far Manor are behind. The air intakes are huge even compared to Haas.
Thanks Keith, this was really cool.
his_majesty
8th March 2016, 0:48
I can see a little bit of graining in every Renault picture. Granted we don’t know how many laps they did on them when the pictures were taken, but it will be interesting to see if they have a problem.
Scottie (@scottie)
8th March 2016, 1:21
The rear suspension geometry is fascinating to compare also! totally different between a few of the teams. Will be interesting to see the pro’s and con’s on track.
Great great feature Keith! Fantastic!
JohnR
8th March 2016, 1:47
Very nice. Is there a top view that compares side to side instead of front to back?
BlueChris (@bluechris)
8th March 2016, 7:36
Do you notice the Mercedes Air Box? its totally huge in comparison to the other big teams… i wonder why really. Williams and the other teams with the same engine has smaller Air Box inlet… i dont know why they did that really..
Sean Newman
8th March 2016, 8:23
Well Keith, great article in terms of detail and comparison.
Although I’d beg to differ regarding you view on the idea that if all of the cars were painted the same it would be hard to tell the difference. Of course the close ups and side by side comparisons highlight the differences yes but this isn’t something we see very often.
We mostly see the cars whizzing around the track at great speed and for me this is where telling the cars apart gets more difficult. Bold individual colour schemes are needed, the Sauber is a good example, there is no mistaking that car! I’m not saying the rest are bad, they just could be better that’s all.
Imagine West Ham versus Aston Villa, both playing in their claret and blue or Bayern Munich versus Liverpool. That would be confusing! Cars do look the same compared to years gone by. This make the colour schemes vital!
Keep up the good work Keith.
JB
8th March 2016, 8:57
Brilliant work Keith! I like how streamlined the W07 is.
Saurabh (@sksahukanker62)
8th March 2016, 20:10
i love this way of comparing the cars. This puts an end to the people’s notion that all the F1 cars look the same. Also this feature takes the site to another level… :)
Gabriel (@naylamp)
9th March 2016, 0:19
damn it, Keith! my productivity will go down at my job this week… for sure. thanks.
Euro Brun (@eurobrun)
9th March 2016, 7:36
Late to the party, but love this feature.
Also love the double functionality as a B.A.R. livery generator.
BasCB (@bascb)
9th March 2016, 9:38
Really love this feature @keithcollantine! I have to stop myself from staying here all day to compare all the different cars in all views.