Villeneuve’s binary season goes on as Panis charges to second

1997 Spanish Grand Prix flashback

Posted on

| Written by

Williams arrived at the sixth round of the 1997 world championship following a humiliating race in Monaco. They left the Principality point-less after sending both their cars out on slick tyres in wet conditions.

The choice of tyre would be much more straightforward at the sunny Circuit de Catalunya. But as the mercury rose it became increasingly clear Williams’ tyre supplier Goodyear was feeling the heat from new rivals Bridgestone.

1997 Spanish Grand Prix qualifying

Michael Schumacher had inserted his Ferrari between the Williams cars in qualifying at Monaco. But in Spain the battle for the top two places was an all-Williams affair – the rest of the field was almost a second off the pace of the FW19s.

Heinz-Harald Frentzen was on course to repeat his Monaco pole position as the minutes ticked down. But a later flier from Jacques Villeneuve put the other Williams ahead, despite putting two wheels in the first at the final corner.

Frentzen tried to hit back but couldn’t match his team mate’s pace, and Villeneuve had his fifth pole position of the year. The softer tyres had helped cut over four seconds off the 1996 pole position time, but the pressing question was how well they’d stand up in the race.

Schumacher, whose Monaco win had put him on top of the points standings, had a tough time. Ferrari’s new Evo II engine still wasn’t reliable: they’d blown four examples in pre-season testing and another one went during practice. Schumacher was the best part of two seconds off with his final effort, which left him seventh.

He was separated from the Williams drivers first by David Coulthard. Mercedes had brought their new F110 engine which was good for 740bhp, and Coulthard prevailed in a close fight for ‘best of the rest’.

Jean Alesi narrowly bumped the second McLaren of Mika Hakkinen back to row three. Fourth on the grid was by far his best of the season so far, and a useful riposte to growing speculation over his future at the team.

Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter and go ad-free

With Gerhard Berger up in sixth it was looking like a much better weekend for Benetton. Technical chief Pat Symonds admitted the B197 was working much better at a track which stressed the tyres more than it had at lower-grip venues like Monaco.

The two Jordans lined up behind Schumacher, the world champion’s younger brother only slightly slower than his team mate. Johnny Herbert completed the top ten in his Sauber.

Herbert had a new team mate for this race. Ferrari test driver Nicola Larini had been ejected in favour of Gianni Morbidelli, but the team’s new driver had a fright during practice. He lost control of his car at the pit exit and skidded broadside across the track, in a manner reminiscent of Berger’s bizarre crash at Estoril four years earlier.

The second Ferrari of Eddie Irvine took 11th ahead of the first Bridgestone-shod runner. Olivier Panis knew his rubber would work much better over a race stint than it had during a single flying lap.

Reigning world champion Damon Hill had to settle for 15th on the grid after exceeding his maximum allocation of practice laps. He was penalised one lap from his qualifying allocation, meaning he was only allowed 11 laps instead of the usual 12.

1997 Spanish Grand Prix grid

Row 1 1. Jacques Villeneuve 1’16.525
2. Heinz-Harald Frentzen 1’16.791
Row 2 3. David Coulthard 1’17.521
4. Jean Alesi 1’17.717
Row 3 5. Mika Hakkinen 1’17.737
6. Gerhard Berger 1’18.041
Row 4 7. Michael Schumacher 1’18.313
8. Giancarlo Fisichella 1’18.385
Row 5 9. Ralf Schumacher 1’18.423
10. Johnny Herbert 1’18.494
Row 6 11. Eddie Irvine 1’18.873
12. Olivier Panis 1’19.157
Row 7 13. Gianni Morbidelli 1’19.323
14. Mika Salo 1’20.079
Row 8 15. Damon Hill 1’20.089
16. Shinji Nakano 1’20.103
Row 9 17. Rubens Barrichello 1’20.255
18. Jarno Trulli 1’20.452
Row 10 19. Jos Verstappen 1’20.582
20. Ukyo Katayama 1’20.672
Row 11 21. Pedro Diniz 1’21.029
22. Jan Magnussen 1’21.060

1997 Spanish Grand Prix

If Williams’ tyre choice had been derided in Monaco, this time they were the ones smiling. “Before the race we laughed when we saw Ferrari on new tyres,” said Villeneuve. “There was just no way.”

Many of the Goodyear runners had struggled to get the same life from their tyres the Bridgestone teams had found. Ferrari’s lack of downforce meant they were giving their tyres more abuse than most, and the bold decision to use a fresh set of tyres for the race backfired.

The decision played into Villeneuve’s hands, however. He got away cleanly at the start while Frentzen slipped back and Schumacher rocketed away on his fresh rubber. Coulthard briefly tried to sit it out with Villeneuve at turn one but fell back into the clutches of Schumacher.

Lap two therefore began with Villeneuve in the happy position of having his closest rival in second place but already struggling on his tyres and holding the rest of the field up. Schumacher headed for the pits with blistered right-rear tyres after just 13 laps by which time Villeneuve’s lead was already over 20 seconds.

Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter and go ad-free

Coulthard had finally succeeded in passing Schumacher just before the pair of them pitted. He emerged well clear of the Ferrari. Villeneuve held on until lap 20 when he handed the lead to Alesi. The Benetton’s kindness to its tyres was now a major strength and Alesi also rejoined ahead of Schumacher after his stop.

But the Goodyear runners’ early stops had brought Panis into contention. Eleventh by the end of lap one, the Prost made it into the podium places before his first pit stop. After that he picked off Alesi and breezed past the three-stopping Coulthard to move back into the top three.

Another Bridgestone runner who showed great pace was Hill. He was running fifth, three places ahead of Panis, at one stage. But on lap 18 his Yamaha cried enough. “He was by far the quickest car on the track when the engine blew,” rued Arrows team boss Tom Walkinshaw. “A first three finish was going to be quite easy.”

While one Williams was eradicating the memories of Monaco, the other was reliving them. Frentzen’s FW19 was trashing its right-rear tyre so badly he was a minute behind after 38 laps. “It was looking good this morning,” he reflected afterwards. “But it was a real disaster for me this weekend.”

Villeneuve’s early lead had protected him from the rapid Panis. The dark blue Prost took around a second lap off Villeneuve in the final stint so that the pair crossed the line 5.8 seconds apart.

Alesi also went the distance with just two pit stops to take third place, a result he described as “oxygen” for his team. But the Benetton driver was unhappy at the amount of time he’d lost behind the lapped Irvine while coming under pressure for position from the other Ferrari.

“I was worried about Irvine because I know he’s such a very strange driver,” Alesi admitted afterwards. “To overtake him was quite tough, much more than keeping Michael behind.”

Villeneuve’s win put him back on top in the points
Panis also lost time behind Irvine, leading team owner Alain Prost to complain if Olivier or Shinji [Nakano] would have been in Irvine’s position I’m sure that we would have got a penalty much before that.”

Irvine, who was given a ten-second penalty for his driving, insisted it had been a misunderstanding. “Me and [Jos] Verstappen were trying to lap one of the Minardis so I assumed the blue flag was for that,” he said. “The team never told me [Panis] was a lap ahead.”

Schumacher was unable to capitalise on his team mate’s help, inadvertent or otherwise. He led the three-stoppers in fourth, followed by Coulthard.

Herbert slipped by Hakkinen on the final lap to take fifth. Frentzen came in a distance eighth, followed by Fisichella and Berger. The latter had been fortunate to start from his grid position after stalling at the initial start. The second start was abandoned when Ralf Schumacher stalled too, giving Berger a second chance.

Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter and go ad-free

Villeneuve’s win continued his binary campaign. He now had three wins and three no-scores, though it was enough to wrest the lead back from Schumacher.

But was his biggest challenge about to come from elsewhere? Second place for Panis was the best result yet for Bridgestone. Hirohide Hamashima reckoned his company now had Goodyear “very worried.”

“After all, we were supplying only lower ranked teams, and getting results so much better than expected. I was sure the top teams had all been asking hard questions.”

The prospect of a Bridgestone victory before the end of the season seemed increasingly strong. Panis looked like the driver most likely to deliver it. But a cruel twist of luck lay around the corner, and this race proved his final visit to the F1 podium.

1997 Spanish Grand Prix result

Pos. No. Driver Team Laps Time / gap / reason
1 3 Jacques Villeneuve Williams-Renault 64 1hr 30’35.896
2 14 Olivier Panis Prost-Mugen-Honda 64 5.804
3 7 Jean Alesi Benetton-Renault 64 12.534
4 5 Michael Schumacher Ferrari 64 17.979
5 16 Johnny Herbert Sauber-Petronas 64 27.986
6 10 David Coulthard McLaren-Mercedes 64 29.744
7 9 Mika Hakkinen McLaren-Mercedes 64 48.785
8 4 Heinz-Harald Frentzen Williams-Renault 64 1’04.139
9 12 Giancarlo Fisichella Jordan-Peugeot 64 1’04.767
10 8 Gerhard Berger Benetton-Renault 64 1’05.670
11 18 Jos Verstappen Tyrrell-Ford 63 1 lap
12 6 Eddie Irvine Ferrari 63 1 lap
13 23 Jan Magnussen Stewart-Ford 63 1 lap
14 17 Gianni Morbidelli Sauber-Petronas 62 2 laps
15 21 Jarno Trulli Minardi-Hart 62 2 laps
2 Pedro Diniz Arrows-Yamaha 53 Engine
11 Ralf Schumacher Jordan-Peugeot 50 Engine
22 Rubens Barrichello Stewart-Ford 37 Engine
19 Mika Salo Tyrrell-Ford 35 Tyre
15 Shinji Nakano Prost-Mugen-Honda 34 Gearbox
1 Damon Hill Arrows-Yamaha 17 Engine
20 Ukyo Katayama Minardi-Hart 11 Gearbox

Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter and go ad-free

1997 Spanish Grand Prix championship standings

Become a RaceFans Supporter

RaceFans is run thanks in part to the generous support of its readers. By contributing £1 per month or £12 per year (or the same in whichever currency you use) you can help cover the costs of creating, hosting and developing RaceFans today and in the future.

Become an RaceFans Supporter today and browse the site ad-free. Sign up or find out more via the links below:

Author information

Keith Collantine
Lifelong motor sport fan Keith set up RaceFans in 2005 - when it was originally called F1 Fanatic. Having previously worked as a motoring...

Got a potential story, tip or enquiry? Find out more about RaceFans and contact us here.

10 comments on “Villeneuve’s binary season goes on as Panis charges to second”

  1. That top picture! Good god I miss grass at Grand Prix.

    1. Pero (@peronakov)
      25th May 2017, 12:55


    2. Unicron (@unicron2002)
      25th May 2017, 13:21

      So, so true! If only the grass had been kept, and then the gravel was replaced by tarmac.

    3. @bamboo I have followed F1 only since the last 4-5 years. Wouldn’t the grass be really un-helpful in wet conditions??
      I mean really really un-helpful? Slightest tyre on the grass (muddish) and no chance for the car?

      1. Yes, but that made driver skill and car control all the more important. Nowadays the tracks can be too forgiving. For safety reasons you could argue that wet grass doesn’t slow a car down a lot, but then I would prefer a different solution to that than laying tarmac which just makes it easier to miss the corner and get away with it. There’s enough smart people in F1 to solve that puzzle, but they’re not interested, it seems.

  2. One of the best F1 races ever I think. Coulthard was very fast in the early stages, but somehow he faded badly during the race. Schumacher, on the other hand, had serious tire issues in the early part of the race, but neatly recovered from it (so apparently used tires were the secret). Fisichella set the fastest lap of the race, but failed to score points. Villeneuve was nursing his tires a lot, so he only had to stop twice, just like Alesi, while their respective teammates Frentzen and Berger were struggling with the tires all afternoon. And then of course there was Panis, who had been running behind Irvine early in the race, but finished a lap ahead in second place.

    By the way, Herbert passed Coulthard’s McLaren for fifth in the final lap.

    1. Unicron (@unicron2002)
      25th May 2017, 16:04

      It’s a shame that you think this was one of the best races because I had to watch it in Spain, in Spanish – which I do not speak! So trying to follow an F1 race with no commentary meant that the drivers being shuffled about due to strategy was pretty much lost on me. I just remember willing Panis on at the end, getting angry at Irvine for holding him up for so long and wondering how Panis had got there in the first place!

      1. @unicron2002 In my country the commentary isn’t that good either, so for me it was really interesting to watch some ancient races with British commentary. They give a lot of background information. However, there are also many races with Brazilian/Portuguese commentary which I do not understand, so then I’m just trying to enjoy the race. Luckily I usually know what will happen, so that helps. If you’re watching a race live without good commentary it’s a completely different story because you have no idea what’s going on. I must say this probably was one of the more confusing races because of the high number of pitstops and the exceptionally strong race pace of the Bridgestone drivers.

  3. But was his biggest challenge about to come from elsewhere? Second place for Panis was the best result yet for Bridgestone. Hirohide Hamashima reckoned his company now had Bridgestone “very worried.”

    Should this say Goodyear?

Comments are closed.