F1 2017 by Codemasters reviewed

F1 review

Posted on

| Written by

The end of August is always a good time of year to be a Formula One fan.

Not only does the sport return from its summer break for one of the best grands prix of the season at Spa, it’s also the traditional release window of Codemasters’s official F1 game.

After producing their best entry to date in 2016, does this season’s edition manage to improve on a winning formula or see the series fall back into the pack?

New season, new cars

While Liberty Media continue to forge a new future for Formula One, Codemasters remain sadly shackled by the restrictions of the licence agreement they signed in the Ecclestone era. That means there is still no active driver market or new additions to the calendar in career mode – features that have long been near the top of fans’ wishlists.

That said, despite the restrictions on them, it’s hard to think of what more Codemasters could add to this season’s official game.

This season’s new generation cars at the true stars at the heart of F1 2017 – and fans will enjoy getting to put F1’s fastest ever machines through their paces.

The additional downforce and wider tyres of this year’s regulations mean there’s so much more mid-corner grip available. It’s just plain fun to throw the cars into the corners without having to worry about running out of grip, while the harder tyres for this season means you can afford to push more without feeling restricted by tyre degradation.

Go ad-free for just £1 per month

>> Find out more and sign up

Car performance feels authentic too. Ferrari and Mercedes will trade wins with Red Bull hanging around just behind to capitalise should the opportunity present itself. Race as Williams and get the difficulty level right for you and you’ll find yourself unable to touch the front runners while trying holding off the Force India duo of Ocon and Perez.

Monaco can be tackled as a night race
And it’s so much easier to find that perfect difficulty setting with the long-awaited introduction of a difficulty slider. You can now select the AI performance on a one-to-110 percent scale, allowing you to strike that perfect balance between challenge and fun and even adjust for each circuit if you’re finding performance inconsistent between the 20 tracks.

The default wheel settings – at least on a Logitech G29 – feel good, but veterans will probably want to play with the saturation and linearity to find a better sensation of car on road. Controller users will be pleased to learn that this year’s game feels more responsive on a pad than last year.

Graphically, F1 2017 is of identical quality to what 2016 offered. While it wasn’t possible to test on a PlayStation 4 Pro, players on that system will be able to enjoy 4k resolution and HDR enhancements to visuals. Presentation of this year’s game has also been enhanced by the official FOM graphics making their first ever appearance in the series during pre-race cinematics.

Bringing back the classics

Classic mode has returned to the series
The 2017 cars are a lot of fun to drive but this year’s blockbuster feature is the welcome return of classic Formula One cars for the first time since their one-off appearance in the 2013 edition.

There are 12 classic challengers covering the last 30 years of the sport, from the McLaren MP4/4 of 1988 to Sebastian Vettel’s championship-winning Red Bull RB6 of 2010. Fans may feel a little disappointed that some of the sport’s earlier eras are not represented, but as a 27-year-old lifelong fan, it was personally very enjoyable to recognise so many cars that I already felt an emotional connection to.

The cars available cover a V12, V10 and V8 engine eras and all can be raced at the same time on any circuit with the option to separate the race into two classes. While the classics’ handling can feel like more of an approximation of their performance rather than truly bespoke for each machine, every single car on show here offers something different and nuanced.

There’s a lot of enjoyment to be had simply from picking a circuit in Time Trial mode, running a few laps in Mika Hakkinen’s McLaren MP4-13 before using the pause menu to quickly switch to Lewis Hamilton’s MP4-23 and feeling the difference a decade of evolution can make.

Deepest career mode yet

Career mode remains but drivers still can’t swap teams
Career mode is back in much the same form as last year, but Codemasters have brought some major upgrades for the new season. The interesting research and design feature from 2016 has been completely transformed and now gives players far greater depth to develop their cars.

You can now choose from over 100 upgrades to earn over the course of your ten-season career, covering aerodynamics, powertrain, chassis and reliability upgrades and even some extra team based bonuses. You’re at liberty to choose what to upgrade and when, allowing you to strategically focus on improving your car’s weakness or enhancing its strengths. Don’t worry if it seems intimidating at first, there’s plenty of information available to help make your choices and you can even follow the engineer’s recommendations if you prefer.

Reliability is also a key focus for career this year as now you’ll have to consider the health of all of your power unit components and gearboxes. The more you use and abuse your ICE, your MGU-H or ERS, the more they’ll wear. If you’re not careful, you’ll push your parts to a potential race-ending failure and a grid penalty for the next event.

Component wear scales with race distance and the game makes it clear how close each of your power unit parts or gearboxes are to the end of their predicted lives with live data available on the HUD during races. It’s unlikely you’ll have too much trouble avoiding grid penalties unless you run a lot of laps in practice sessions.

Combine the upgrades and reliability systems together and career season really do feel like one long, continuous campaign as opposed to just a series of single races. While career mode remains the most satisfying part of the series, it does feel like the hardcore fans looking for that authentically challenging full F1 experience will get the most from the experience this year.

On track, F1 2017 offers more of the racing experience that was so immersive last year. With all the authenticity options activated, full distance grands prix have never been as enthralling on consoles as they are in F1 2017.

New ‘invitational events’ in career mode provide bitesized challenges for players to take on using the classic cars. From overtaking challenges requiring you to pass a set number of cars in a time limit to checkpoint challenges, they’re a welcome addition to the series. But beyond their initial novelty value, hardcore players will probably find themselves skipping these events during their careers.

Nuts and bolts

Codemasters have added new game modes
But there’s more. Custom Championships are an extra addition that will provide players with even more fun outside of the main career mode. Based on themes such as street circuits, wet weather, endurance or double header events, these shorter championships cover both 2017 and classic cars and provide some compact but entertaining challenges for players to beat.

The Monaco Grand Prix can now be run at night, which looks spectacular with the Monte Carlo streets illuminated by shining lights. Shortened alternative versions of Sakhir, Silverstone, Suzuka and the Circuit of the Americas also provide a little extra variety to the track list.

Hardcore fans of Codemasters’s series will also appreciate some of the ‘quality of life’ improvements that have been made to this year’s edition. Booting up the game for the first time, you can import your F1 2016 save and have all your settings and career profile carried over to allow to get right into playing.

Players can now create up to ten career mode drivers to each profile, each with their own name, driver number, helmet design and avatar. This means you can start a full, 100% distance career for Williams, run a 50% career for Red Bull and a casual five lap Haas career simultaneously, switching between them whenever you want.

The new cars are great fun to drive
The ability to save multiple controller setting presets is a small but very welcome feature that will make it far easier to play around and find the right steering saturation and force feedback settings for your pad and your wheel or even have different settings saved for different cars.

The occasional problems that do exist, however, can be frustrating.

On a standard PS4, helmet textures did occasionally become blurry. We did also experience a small graphical clipping glitch on some of the cars while in T-cam view, although admittedly this was after the T-cam camera settings had been adjusted from their defaults.

What is less forgivable is how difficult it became to read some of the game’s text was. In a move to perhaps embrace the current console generation’s move into 4k resolution, the text size seems to have been reduced this year. On a reasonably sized TV running in 1080p resolution, it was occasionally very difficult to make out laptimes or read crucial race data on display, which was not a problem in F1 2016.

Similarly, when racing in cockpit view in a Williams, the race engineer menu and text from the game’s overwise informative HUD was completely lost against the FW40’s white livery.

While there is so much new content in the game, it is a little disappointing see so many cutscenes, animations and presentation elements recycled directly from last year’s game.

Codemasters’s best yet?

Authentic and fun: F1 2017 strikes a fine balance
But the fact that these are the most outstanding issues from a fair few hours of play reflects that Codemasters have again produced a Formula One game that is truly deserving of their licence.

The series will never provide the fully realistic, hardcore simulation of the sport that so many ardent simracers would ideally want it to, but with so many quality sims available on the market and more soon to be released, Codemasters know their series doesn’t have to go that way.

Instead, F1 2017 manages to hit a very satisfying balance between authenticity and accessibility. From the feel of the new 2017 beasts to the variety provided by the classics, a deeper career experience, new custom championships and a host of minor improvements, there’s an awful lot available for players to enjoy this season.

It’s never been easier to recommend an official game to both casual fans and lifelong enthusiasts of the sport.

F1 Fanatic rating

Buy F1 2017 Special Edition for for PlayStation 4

Buy F1 2017 Special Edition for Xbox One

Buy F1 2017 Special Edition for PC

Win F1 2017

We’ve got copies of F1 2017 to win every weekend in the Predictions Championship. Make your grand prix predictions before qualifying each weekend for your chance to win. Enter here:

F1 2017

Publisher: Codemasters
Published: 2017
Price: £54.99 (PlayStation 4 and Xbox One), £39.99 (PC)


Browse all Reviews

Author information

Will Wood
Will has been a RaceFans contributor since 2012 during which time he has covered F1 test sessions, launch events and interviewed drivers. He mainly...

Got a potential story, tip or enquiry? Find out more about RaceFans and contact us here.

12 comments on “F1 2017 by Codemasters reviewed”

  1. I’ve enjoyed the game a lot so far. I can definitely feel the difference between say W08 and W07 from last year’s edition through the high-speed corners especially sector 1 of Suzuka feels crazy quick in the current Mercedes, and regarding the classic cars: The 2002 and 2004 Ferrari’s are OP on the straights compared to the other classic cars (especially the V8-powered ones).

  2. Yowser. Didn’t even read it after seeing the utterly terrible screenshot at the top. I own multiple F1 versions from CM, seen enough online reviews and this one looks like another full priced DLC. “12 months” of work for some minor graphics and UI tweeks with a few updates such as classics to grab the gullible, buy the ’88 McLaren if you pay up early, I laugh at those who exclaimed online how without a Senna version, it was a no buy. Face palms all around.

  3. I presume it doesn’t have a 2 player mode (ie you can sit in the same actual room as your real-life friend and play against them and and AI grid) so unfortunately I won’t be buying it! Which is extremely annoying. And yes, gaming wise I am old. First gaming memory is Tennage Mutant Hero Turtle on the NES.

    1. Unfortunately that’s my thoughts to. I still regularly replay the splitscreen championship in 2011 but they’ve removed that feature completely over the last few games – they’re still good games but I usually get them cheap later now.

  4. Is it me or are graphics getting worse and worse each year? These animated drivers are like those from Racing team manager, and graphics overall aint that impresive. The same old story is with the rear wings being undestructable, and wheel contacts do not make u spin or flip u in the air. Damage model also looks stiff. Also i really really dont understand what is up with this mashing up of classic cars racing each other from different periods. Would it not be more interesting to set a separate development team to make F1 series from lets say 1989 – 2008? Make a platform of the game and then make an every season a buyable add on. Or atleast make separate F1 games of old seasons. For me this game is buyable only after a year or two, when the price drops dramaticly – which also says alot of overall quality of the game.

    1. Also i really dislike u are unable to continue when youre fron wheel falls off. I hate when u are automaticly retired.

      1. @proteus Because in real life they continue on 3 wheels right?

  5. Just done a quick race and it does feel like they’ve made some good improvements to the menus etc. Then I jumped in a FW14B and you could really see how the cars have improved. Then I tried to join a game online and it just hung… classic CM….

  6. One thing I wish was included is a few classic tracks. I don’t really wanna race the MP4/4 on a boring car park of a circuit like Abu Dhabi.

  7. Ah for once I’ll be quite (hold on) positive. The game comes from already from inflated niche in gaming (auto-sport is growing but a niche in gaming, don’t shoot the messenger) but they are improving and Codemasters has finally made this a decent sim-game and not a proper arcade any-more.

    But bottom-line is;
    1. Career mode is almost as immerse as in real-life. The practise and R&D (The tech tree has 117(!), and takes much longer to complete) upgrades over 4 sections and is much more developed then last few years. Early upgrades get you grid penalties later on, and your driving style affects your car. Track lay-outs can change. Best improvements are in here, it’s more developed then kings on that area Rfactor.

    2. There is a improved difficult slider setting. Thank the lord.
    3. They implemented dirty air 2017-style in the game and it is just as annoying as in real life. Very well done.
    There you have it, I said some well-meant positive things about this game. Now…

    Negative Julie
    here again;
    1. The media doesn’t have that quite of an influence like in real-life with his quite sad.
    2. The AI is quite too perfect and doesn’t allow you to catch up and races can be very boring on some circuits, and now especially at the hardest settings you need such a proper touch to beat them in quali on those difficult settings, BUT they also try to fight harder on those more open circuits in races which results in quite nice action from time to time, my point is that its looks good but they all try a set of the same moves (inside-outside, late brake), every single driver, which feels too perfect and not realistic. Verstappen and Massa or Grosjean and Button all drive the same.
    3. Again no sustainability, no transfers in seasons? Not realistic.
    4. Online mode is still poor. Apart from the lag on open channels, people can be lunatics and many folks only get DSQ for some quality wheel to wheel banging. Let alone if you can get racing as open lobbies are like groceries stores = everyone comes and goes in 3 mins.
    5. FFB is terrible. Codemasters doesn’t get this right. You’re almost better off with a joy-stick. The small input lag is quite strange too.
    6. Codemasters’ game engine results in poor graphics. It is very bland, especially on PCs. Rfactor 2 has better graphics and I’m talking about a 4 year old beta game there. The faces are from 2008 AAA-games. Yes Codemasters is not EA but 60$? In that price race you’re almost competing with IRacing’s business model and then you need more.

    7. The damage model is truly ridiculous, you can braze the wall at Singapore Sling or Monaco’s swimming pool with 280 km/h and still not lose anything, not even bodywork, but other times you will try to go quali-daring at the swimming pool or on the inside before the Senna-S and you will lose your whole front wing. Did not change.
    8. No VR support, at all.
    9. Time Trials are just as bland as before.
    10. Because of the new more aggressive AI, especially your fronts can overheat for no reason, even driving like Trulli.
    11. Classic cars had no testing whatsoever, the psychics are off by a lot. I could take Eau Rouge flat out, 130R flat out, even coming out of Mercedes into turn 10 at Hockenheim with nearly all of them, not possible.

    I’m saying Rfactor 2 & IRacing or the others are better in terms of proper car simulation. But if you can only buy one game and you only truly like F1 buy it, this year it’s good enough. It is still a semi-arcade but it does a better job in other aspects which improves the hardcore-sim-feel. I will wait what the mod-community will do and buy maybe AC or Rfactor 2 (once the new DirectX gets bug-free). As they give you some better aspect in terms of graphics or overall race-day simulation (the former being good on the eye, the latter being wonderful for online racing but requiring more mod-tweaking for offline) (I’m excluding IRacing as I’m talking mostly about the offline experience and PC2 because it’s a arcade comparing it to Rfactor mods).

    Conclusion, Best yet? True and buy it if you like F1 but in the in the land of the blind the one eyed man is king.

  8. I come up very late here, but I just bought this game for few dollars on steam since it runs on Linux and there is no more recent versions yet on this OS.
    I am a big fan on F1 in general and also in games since the 8bit machines. I had a break due to work and family reasons. Then I just come back.
    To my humble opinion this is not a good F1 game at all. It is almost impossible (even with FFB wheels) to feel the car, so you often take corners too short or too widely. It is also extremely difficult to know when to brake or when to push the gas. The helping line and squares are not helpful at all neither: they can be fully green but you end up in the grass, or them being orange and take the corner like Hamilton never could to stay alive…
    The AI is a joke, they follow too strictly the lines and can crash into you without concern and you end up with a penalty, whether you’re preceding them or trying to take advantage of them. In corners, even in hard mode (60% I guess), then brake too early and it’s always a drama in the first corner.
    In time trial, some players obviously cheat (run straight instead of braking and taking the corner appropriately) but their time got validated ! 1 mn 10 in Monza for example (use them as ghost and you’ll see). But for you (me), if you just get slightly out of the road, then your time will be invalidated… Even if you lost time…
    For multiplayer mode, most of real players are awful, they enjoy slamming on you, wait for you in order to crash you, so this mode is completely useless.

Comments are closed.