Louis Camilleri,

Analysis: Why there is no quick fix for Ferrari’s latest major setback

2020 F1 season

Posted on

| Written by

During Ferrari’s Luca Cordero di Montezemolo era there was absolutely no doubt who was boss of the legendary brand: smart, stylish, suave and sharp, the highly educated and Piedmont-born nobleman epitomised every aspect of Ferrari. He played his audiences – be they media members, Ferrari owners, sponsors or hordes of tifosi – to utter perfection, with multilingual quips and quotes invariably at the ready.

He had been born to the role, and delivered on every front: having been appointed head of the Scuderia in 1974 at the age of 27, he led Ferrari to its first Formula 1 title (with Niki Lauda) in a dozen years the following season. He then did the rounds of Italian business, overseeing Cinzano, holding increasingly senior roles at Fiat and chairing the 1990 football World Cup tournament and Italy’s Americas Cup entry before returning to Ferrari.

As president and CEO Montezemolo reorganised a company in chaos after the death in 1988 of its founder and rejuvenated the racing division through recruitment of the best in the business and letting them get on with it. A multi-national team, headed by Jean Todt, delivered a record-setting run of world championships via Michael Schumacher.

In 2014 Montezemolo was ousted by Sergio Marchionne. Sartorially Montezemolo’s polar opposite – the former donned a black jumper day in, day out – the Italo-Canadian was utterly ruthless, an industrialist of few words and fewer outward emotions. He had a habit of lighting new cigarettes from the butts of old, but is said to have given up the habit shortly before his untimely death.

Rubens Barrichello, Luca di Montezemolo, Jean Todt, Michael Schumacher, Ferrari F2002 launch, 2002
Ferrari enjoyed huge success under Montezemolo
A self-confessed ‘Capital Junkie’, Marchionne spun Ferrari out of the Fiat Chrysler Alliance – he headed both – albeit as a purveyor of luxury goods, not an automotive brand. It worked: Ferrari’s initial public offering (RACE) opened at $52 in October 2015; 30 months later the stock traded at triple that. Marchionne’s plan was to retire from Fiat in March 2019, then devote his twilight years to Ferrari as hands-on president and CEO.

As with Montezemolo there were no doubts who was boss, with numerous tales attesting to his biting tongue. His take-no-prisoners debating style was rarely bettered and his withering look disarmed dissenters. ‘Steely’ best summed up this arch-typical alpha male who had gotten the better of Montezemolo. But, in July 2018, Marchionne passed away unexpectedly from post-surgery complications.

John Elkann, Agnelli scion and chairman of Ferrari and Fiat parent Exor, reflexively parachuted in tobacco baron Louis C Camilleri – who, as top man of the Scuderia’s title partner and principal sponsor Philip Morris (Marlboro and Mission Winnow), sat on Ferrari’s board – initially in an acting CEO position. However, the Ferrari board later ratified a permanent appointment.

Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter and go ad-free

Sergio Marchionne, Ferrari, 2016
Marchionne’s tenure at the top was tragically cut short
There are no doubts that the Egyptian-born Maltese was a capable fast-moving goods executive, having worked his way up to the top Philip Morris office via a series of food and tobacco industry appointments. He is highly spoken of by those in the know and no doubt performed a superb support role on Ferrari’s board. That said, discussions about Camilleri with F1 and auto folk are generally qualified with a whispered “but…”

The perception was that his appointment was fortunate rather than fought for, and that he knew it. Where Montezemolo and Marchionne were car guys he was a caricature of ‘Marlboro Man’. Whenever I saw Camilleri in the F1 paddock, at motor shows or on TV he appeared ill at ease; indeed, I oft wondered where the boss was. It could not last: On Friday Camilleri announced his retirement, citing “personal reasons”.

Under his tenure Ferrari appears to have gone ‘soft’ – on the road car side and in F1. Would Montezemolo or Marchionne have so sanguinely accepted their slump to sixth in the 2020 championship? Would they so readily have acceded to regulatory amendments that severely impact on Ferrari, more so than other teams? The word is Marchionne more often threatened use of Ferrari’s veto than all his predecessors combined, yet Camilleri did so not once.

There are also questions hanging over the deliverability of Ferrari’s future profit targets and model line-up at a time when the entire motor industry is undergoing unprecedented change. The Purosangue sports utility vehicle, designed to push volumes beyond 10,000 units per year without diluting model exclusivity, has been pushed out a year – a decision taken before Covid-19 struck – which will surely hit profit targets.

Even cash-strapped Aston Martin delivered its 4×4 DBX on time. Racing Point, under common majority ownership and to be renamed the Aston Martin F1 Team, is on target to finish third in this year’s championship. Daimler recently upped its stake in the James Bond brand to 20%.

Charles Leclerc, Ferrari, Bahrain International Circuit, 2020
Ferrari are suffering their worst season in decades
Elsewhere Lamborghini is going great guns – via VW Group technologies – while former Ferrari sister brand Maserati, under the FCA umbrella, has just launched a mid-engined supercar. Having been cut loose from Fiat, Ferrari has no such familial ties.

True, despite the ravaging effects of Covid-19, Ferrari’s share price rose 50% in the 30 months of Camilleri’s stewardship, but the flipside is that it spiked briefly when news of his resignation broke – an indicator of market perceptions. Harsh maybe, but Camilleri is unlikely to be missed by Ferrari in the longer term.

Ferrari sources told RaceFans that he had recently been hospitalised in New York after suffering a serious bout of Covid-19, which led him to re-assess his lifestyle. He simultaneously resigned from both his Ferrari and Philip Morris duties. That said, he had started winding down before Ferrari called urgently, and the gig had not formed part of a wider career plan; any wonder he has now decided to step back at the age of 65?

Advert | Become a Supporter & go ad-free

The question facing Elkann is whom to appoint as replacement. The decision could not tax his mind at a more pressing time: Not only is the internal combustion engine – of which Ferrari is a leading proponent – under siege, but FCA is on the brink of merging with PSA (Peugeot/Citroen/Opel). EU approval has been granted, with Elkann slated to be chairman of what will be the world’s fourth-largest automaker, trading as Stellantis.

Louis Carey Camilleri, Mattia Binotto, Monza, 2019
Binotto was Camilleri’s appointment to run the team
This leaves Ferrari team principal Mattia Binotto in an invidious position: Against a background of what is likely to be Ferrari’s worst championship result in four decades his immediate superior is now two levels removed and embroiled in bigger things than the Scuderia. Some massive decisions, such as restructuring the team in the face of the budget cap, need to be taken and a number of these will require approval.

The issue, though, is that there is no clear-cut succession plan. Incoming F1 boss Stefano Domenicali had an illustrious career with the Scuderia before being treated shabbily and cut loose in 2014. He subsequently joined Lamborghini, where his role as CEO is hallmarked by a doubling of sales and the introduction of the Urus SUV. He is said to have been previously offered the Ferrari gig, but declined firmly.

“Stefano is joining Formula 1 on the 1st of January and is looking forward to this new and exciting challenge,” an F1 spokesperson told RaceFans. “Any rumour or speculation otherwise is wrong.” After all, why should he consider going back when he can look forward?

Another potential F1 candidate is Mercedes F1 boss Toto Wolff, who lost out to Domenicali in the race for F1’s top job, but Elkann is said to have been annoyed by comments made by the Austrian during the Ferrari fuel flow controversy, so an enormous amount of water needs to flow under that bridge. Thus Elkann will need to go head-hunting – a long and laborious process that usually entails gardening leave.

There appears to be no quick fix in sight.

Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter and go ad-free

Join the RaceFans Supporters Drive!

RaceFans Supporter Drive If you've enjoyed RaceFans' motor sport coverage during 2020, please take a moment to find out more about our Supporter Drive.

We're aiming to welcome 3,000 new Supporters to help fund RaceFans so we can continue to produce quality, original, independent motorsport coverage. Here's what we're asking for and why - and how you can sign up:

2020 F1 season

Browse all 2020 F1 season articles

Author information

Dieter Rencken
Dieter Rencken has held full FIA Formula 1 media accreditation since 2000, during which period he has reported from over 300 grands prix, plus...

Got a potential story, tip or enquiry? Find out more about RaceFans and contact us here.

9 comments on “Analysis: Why there is no quick fix for Ferrari’s latest major setback”

  1. With Ferrari in constant turmoil since 2014 and none of the other teams having the resources to compete, it’s been far too easy for Mercedes to dominate this sport for the last 7 years.

    As much as so many people on here hate Ferrari, the truth is that a competitive Ferrari is the only thing that can make this predictable sport interesting again.

  2. Now imagine being Vettel and trying to win championships with all this **** going on in the motorhomes and back at the factory.

    1. Too true. People underestimate how much of an effect this wouldve had, and how much of a toll this wouldve taken. He showed this season what a class act he is, and it wasnt for lack of trying.

  3. Ugh, Urus, DBX, Purosangue, Caynne.. luxury SUVs are the worst automotive trend and there is no end in sight. Just goes to prove that wealth is wasted on the wealthy.

  4. Absolute non-sense put Wolff into candidates of Maranello higher harmchair. Apart Elkann’a though, Toto stakes 30% of major competitor/enemy which with he’s iron-melted. They’ll go for Mike Manley, that from FCA Ceo will have no room at new Stellantis board.

  5. Fascinating article. I have a feeling the role may stay unfilled long enough for Binotto to apply restructuring without seeking much approval. This would be a great thing, as it would allow them to focus on creating a good team, and ignoring politics. Let’s hope Ferrari bounce back soon, F1 needs them!

  6. He then did the rounds of Italian business, overseeing Cinzano, holding increasingly senior roles at Fiat and chairing the 1990 football World Cup tournament and Italy’s Americas Cup entry before returning to Ferrari.

    For history, Montezemolo also had a disastrous stint at Juventus in 1990/1991 season that started badly with a 5-1 defeat to Napoli of the late Maradona (RIP) and ended disastrously with 7th place in the standing of the Serie A in what is called by the Vecchia Signora tifosi as the “annus horribilis” despite having the new stadium Delle Alpi ready after the world cup and the team didn’t lack great players like Baggio, Schillaci.

    Incoming F1 boss Stefano Domenicali had an illustrious career with the Scuderia before being treated shabbily and cut loose in 2014

    I think that Stefano while being an exceptionally nice human being, he was – with Montezemolo who was busy doing politics in Italy – the direct responsible for the state of the Scuderia today having made 2 crucial errors : the first is that they didn’t invest earlier in simulations, wind tunnel… i.e. modern technology to build an F1 car and having signed the hybrid regulations at the time thinking that they can compete with Mercedes by having the best KERS system in 2009 and 2011 years.

    It has to be said that the first point wasn’t their fault a 100% because Marchionne as a head of the group was squeezing Ferrari on purpose and Domenicali had to deal with the budget allocated to him, that’s why in those years Montezemolo kept lobbying Todt and Ecclestone for regulations change.

    However, once Marchionne as the president understood the importance of spending to win in F1, he never back down and the investments started to flow like upgrades to the wind tunnel, simulator, new Gestione Sportiva HQ, partnership with MAHLE and AVL. The latter failed but it was a good learning process that actually helped develop the PU further in the 2015-2017 years.

    As for the second mistake, that like the KO to Ferrari and F1 in general since the sport is now “hijacked” by Mercedes that controls its destiny. Looking forward to see how Domenicali will deal with a problem he created himself 8 years ago.

    Harsh maybe, but Camilleri is unlikely to be missed by Ferrari in the longer term.

    Camilieri was the CEO of Ferrari N.V., the holding company and was in charge of the commercial part of Ferrari. Elkann is the president of the Scuderia Ferrari or the Gestione Sportiva : the F1 team. I don’t think that Camilieri has failed in his job because he had nothing to do with the F1 team, theoretically speaking. I kind of agree that he won’t be missed. However, due to the solidity of the brand, his replacement will have an easier job than most car companies CEOs.

    Great articles as usual. It’s not only the stories and the insights but as a non native English speaker, I find it challenging to complete Dieter’s articles without ever opening the dictionary and as a result always learning new vocabulary.

  7. One day, someone will rebuild Ferrari…

  8. Ferrari must look forward to 2022 season. They still have time to prepare properly for it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

All comments are moderated. See the Comment Policy and FAQ for more.
If the person you're replying to is a registered user you can notify them of your reply using '@username'.