Start, Laguna Seca, IndyCar, 2021

RaceFans’ top 10 IndyCar drivers of 2021


Posted on

| Written by

The 2021 IndyCar series produced another closely fought, competitive season of racing. Nine different drivers won races including a remarkable four first-time winners.

One of those – Álex Palou – steadily emerged from the pack as the season went on. By the time the drivers assembled in Long Beach for the season finale, Palou’s title seemed nailed-on, Pato O’Ward and Josef Newgarden needing lucky turns which never materialised to keep him from the crown.

The ascent of Palou prevented multiple champions Josef Newgarden and Scott Dixon adding to their piles of silverware. Meanwhile the championship also welcomed ex-Formula 1 driver Romain Grosjean and saw one of his predecessors, Marcus Ericsson, deliver his first victories.

Which among them and their rivals had the best campaigns in 2021? Here’s our verdict:

10. Jack Harvey

Jack Harvey, Meyer Shank, Indianapolis, IndyCar, 2021
Harvey’s bright start to the season faded

Harvey was unlucky not to reach the podium more than once this season – race two at Texas, the Indianapolis GP in May, and Road America are the most obvious examples. But on many weekends, he and the number 60 Meyer Shank Racing team soundly outperformed most of the drivers at Andretti Autosport, from which MSR receives technical support.

He finished 2021 with four top-10 finishes in the last five races, bringing him to 13th in the final standings. He had two fourth-place finishes (St. Petersburg and Portland) and made the Fast Six phase of qualifying four times.

He leaves MSR for Rahal Letterman Lanigan after five seasons (two of them full-time) with both he and the team in a stronger position than when they both began their IndyCar journeys in 2017. Next year, MSR will field two full-time entries for reigning and four-time Indy 500 winner Hélio Castroneves, and Simon Pagenaud, newly acquired from Penske this off-season. Their ability to attract two prolific veteran drivers is a testament to the progress that MSR – and their departing, cornerstone driver – have made along the way.

9. Will Power

Will Power, Penske, IndyCar, Indianapolis Motor Speedway, 2021
Power had a scare in qualifying for the Indianapolis 500

The 2021 season represented a pronounced decline for Power, who finished ninth in the championship, his lowest placement since joining Penske as a full-time driver in 2010. But even if he is in decline, Power was still a productive driver this season.

After narrowly escaping the humiliation of being bumped from the Indianapolis 500 field, Power surged back into form after the mid-season break. He won the second race at Indianapolis this August then took another pole position at Gateway the following week. He finished the year with four podiums, came within half a second of denying Palou the victory in the opening round at Barber and, of course, lost a nailed-on victory at Detroit due to an overheating problem during a red flag period.

It’s likely that the two-year contract extension Power signed in April will be his last full-time IndyCar contract, one that will see him flying the flag for Team Penske until the end of 2023.

Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter and go ad-free

8. Graham Rahal

Graham Rahal, RLL, IndyCar, Barber Motorsport Park, 2021
Quiet in qualifying, Rahal reliably came good in the races

It was another quietly productive if unspectacular season for second-generation driver Rahal in 2021. He still hasn’t won a race since sweeping the 2017 Detroit Grand Prix, and he only finished on the podium once this year, finishing third at the second race in Texas.

His qualifying form continued to be bang-on average, only reaching the final phase of qualifying twice all season. But Rahal consistently fought his way into the top half of the field whenever he could: He finished the year with seven top-fives, 11 top-tens and only two retirements – both caused by accidents that weren’t his fault.

This consistency was one of Rahal’s best traits when he was fighting for championships from 2015 to 2017, and if he can maintain that consistency while being able to qualify near the front at a higher rate, it shouldn’t be long before Rahal finds his way back to the top step of the podium. Additional motivation may come in the form of two new full-time team mates at RLL next year: Harvey, and another driver to be named later.

7. Marcus Ericsson

With a little luck, Ericsson won in Detroit and Nashville

Ericsson took the initiative and began to rewrite the narrative of his racing career in 2021. While he was more than a bit lucky to end up leading and win the first race at Detroit, and again at Nashville, he did not falter once he found himself at the front of the field.

There was more evidence to suggest Ericsson’s breakthrough season wasn’t a fluke. He almost came from behind to win at Mid-Ohio, he scored 12 top-ten finishes, matching his total over his first two seasons. After being within striking distance of the top of the championship table, Ericsson was unlucky to drop to sixth in the final standings following his only retirement at Long Beach.

Ericsson is now looking more and more like the worthy protegé of Indy 500 winner Kenny Bräck as he gains experience. He is not yet officially confirmed at Chip Ganassi Racing for 2022, but it would be a startling development if he ended up elsewhere by the time the 2022 season begins in February.

6. Romain Grosjean

Romain Grosjean, Coyne/Rick War, Laguna Seca, IndyCar, 2021
IndyCar’s latest F1 convert showed bags of potential

While on the subject of F1 veterans that have found new life in IndyCar, Romain Grosjean’s embrace of American racing and his concurrent return to competitive form were one of the feel-good stories of this season. Staking his claim as IndyCar’s “people’s champion” of 2021, Grosjean picked up three podiums – two runner-up finishes at the Indianapolis road course, and a hard-fought third at Laguna Seca.

He won his first pole at the Indianapolis GP in May. Despite running just 13 out of 16 races, Grosjean finished just 33 points behind Scott McLaughlin for the IndyCar Rookie of the Year Award. And he looked confident in his first oval race at Gateway.

There were flare-ups of rookie growing pains and bad luck, but on the whole, Grosjean’s performances at Dale Coyne Racing in 2021 gave Andretti Autosport enough assurance to make him their high-profile free agent signing of the off-season. Next year, Grosjean has a legitimate chance to compete for a championship, as he’ll run the full 17-race schedule – including the Indianapolis 500.

Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter and go ad-free

5. Scott Dixon

Scott Dixon, Ganassi, Texas, IndyCar, 2021
The defending champion won just once and was eclipsed by his team mate

Remarkably, despite winning six IndyCar series titles, Dixon has still never successfully defended any of them, a trend which continued in 2021. He also missed his chance to claim a second Indianapolis 500 victory after qualifying on pole position.

He won just once this year – a dominant victory in race one at Texas – compared to four times in 2021. And yet, because he is Dixon, a disappointing season by his standards still meant leading more laps than any other driver. It meant that he won a race for the 16th year in a row, finished in the top four in the championship table for the 15th time in those 16 years, scored five podiums and 12 top-tens, had a car that was fast enough to win the Indy 500, and took the chequered flag in every race but one – when he was collected in a crash at Gateway.

Because he’s Scott Dixon, it wouldn’t be a massive shock if he were to strike back against his new champion team mate Palou and win his record-equalling seventh national title in 2022.

4. Josef Newgarden

Josef Newgarden, Penske, IndyCar, Barber Motorsport Park, 2021
A third title continues to elude Newgarden, though he won three times

The 2021 season played out a lot like 2020 for Penske driver Josef Newgarden, finishing the year strong to snatch second place in the series championship after fits of poor fortune in the first half of the year. The year was best remembered for the stretch of misfortune that saw victories at Detroit race two and Road America slip away in the closing laps, before finally getting to the top step with victories at Mid-Ohio and Gateway.

Newgarden was once again the star performer at Penske this season. He won four pole positions – the most any driver managed – collected six podiums and 13 top-ten finishes, and led the third most laps. His only retirement came when he crashed on the first lap of the first race at Barber.

If not for that, or the gear selection glitch at Road America, Newgarden may have been able to win his third championship in five years since joining Penske. That third crown will be among the main goals for Newgarden as he begins his tenth season, that much is certain. But he would also like to check off the one box that’s missing from his CV: and win the Indianapolis 500.

3. Patricio O’Ward

O’Ward stayed in the title fight until the end – and earned himself a Formula 1 test

McLaren Racing CEO Zak Brown compared his star driver “Pato” O’Ward to a young Juan Pablo Montoya after O’Ward tore through the field late in the second race at Detroit to take his second win of the season. His ruthless, aggressive style was on display there – and in the second race at Texas, where he took his first career win with a late overtake for the lead.

He was unlucky to drop to third in the final championship standings after a DNF in Long Beach, after leading the points after two races and seeming set to finish runner-up in the table. O’Ward has now finished in the top four in each of his two seasons at McLaren SP. And the quantum leap forward that O’Ward and his McLaren SP crew took in 2021 seems all the more remarkable, when considering that his team mate, Felix Rosenqvist, struggled to find his form for most of the season.

If O’Ward can address his areas of opportunity with tyre management – and at 22 years old, he still has plenty of time to solve that puzzle – multiple IndyCar titles should follow in the years to come.

2. Colton Herta

Colton Herta, Laguna Seca, IndyCar, 2021
A superb end to the season marked Herta out as a 2022 title contender

Without question Herta was the strongest front-runner in IndyCar this season. He demonstrated as such with dominant pole-to-win victories at St. Petersburg and Laguna Seca. But he also showed that he’s not just a strong front-runner, by charging from 14th to win the finale at Long Beach, giving him his third win of 2021, tied for the most wins of any driver this season.

Only Dixon led more laps this year than Herta, and only Newgarden and O’Ward had as many pole positions. Just like O’Ward at McLaren SP, Herta’s successes are highlighted in stark contrast to the lacklustre form of his three team mates at Andretti Autosport. Here is one of IndyCar’s ‘big three’ organisations, and the 21-year-old wunderkind Herta is carrying them on his shoulders virtually every weekend.

Herta’s championship hopes evaporated over the course of four costly retirements. Of those, only the unforced accident at Nashville – where he dominated most of the weekend – could be totally blamed on driver error. A middling 16th place finish at the Indy 500 didn’t help much either, of course. But he’s so close to being the complete package already, needing just a little better execution over the season to take the next step into being an elite driver and perennial championship contender.

1. Álex Palou

Palou unquestionably made for a deserving champion, and has a bright future ahead

Álex Palou walked into Chip Ganassi Racing as an intriguing free-agent signing, and concluded 2021 as IndyCar’s newest series champion.

Alex Palou, Ganassi, IndyCar, Barber Motorsport Park, 2021
IndyCar’s new champion won his first race at Barber
The year began with a first win at Barber. He also won at Road America after inheriting the lead with two laps left, and then in a must-win situation after consecutive DNFs, came back from an early end-of-line penalty to win at Portland.

Palou’s positive demeanour never wavered, even after the DNFs, even after multiple grid penalties left him with a harder job on some weekends to fight back into contention, or any other time when it seemed like the title might slip from his grasp. He drove like a worthy champion all season long.

The only thing that would have made Palou’s breakout 2021 campaign even sweeter, is if he had been able to get past Hélio Castroneves in the last laps to win the Indianapolis 500 in his sophomore season. Or, perhaps, even a wet weather race for him to demonstrate his superb rain driving prowess that he showcased in GP3 and Super Formula.

In 16 races, Palou finished on the podium eight times, and recorded 12 top-ten finishes. Palou’s smooth driving and metronomic consistency echoes that of his senior team mate, Scott Dixon.

Nonetheless he will face a stern test to defend his title in 2022, given the number of young and experienced drivers that also had a chance this season, or those that are projected to take a step forward in the near future. But even after just one year with an elite team, Álex Palou has demonstrated that he is up to the task, and should be for many more years to come.


Browse all IndyCar articles

Author information

RJ O'Connell
Motorsport has been a lifelong interest for RJ, both virtual and ‘in the carbon’, since childhood. RJ picked up motorsports writing as a hobby...

Got a potential story, tip or enquiry? Find out more about RaceFans and contact us here.

21 comments on “RaceFans’ top 10 IndyCar drivers of 2021”

  1. Pat Ruadh (@fullcoursecaution)
    28th October 2021, 12:31

    Strange to see Power on this list and Castroneves not, after he won the big one for Meyer Shank and gave one of the big memories of the year climbing the fence again, but other than that hard to disagree.
    I’d maybe out Ericsson a little higher.

    It’s a crazy stat that Dixon has never defended a title.

    Biggest disappointment of the year:
    It’s a toss up between Rossi (again) and Rosenqvist. Honorable mention to Scott McLaughlin.

  2. I say it again, Palou winning Indy makes indy look bad.
    It is like Quartararo and especially Mir winning motogp.
    You can’t be average your entire career and then win the most important title.
    when this happens in f1, you can blame the car.

    1. Jose Lopes da Silva
      28th October 2021, 14:39

      I generally agree with you. Ericsson’s success in Indycar underligns it – Ericsson never made it to any top10 list in Formula 1, yet here he is.
      Anyway, isn’t possible to have periods in history where the relative balance between drivers makes it also that several of them can win?
      I think what is happening now in MotoGP (now that Rossi got way older and Marquez is driving single-hand) is that the front-runners are just balanced. Are they all average? Are they relatively good, but all of them below top Marquez and top Rossi?
      We had that in Formula 1 between 1976 and 1982, with a different driver winning every year without repeats. Hunt, Andretti, Scheckter, Jones, Rosberg, (Reutemann, Laffite, Villeneuve, Peterson), were all average or were all good but not top? (Lauda and Piquet were top, in my opinion, so I’m counting them out.)

      (Please don’t tell anyone that I’m considering Hunt and Gilles as “just good”, it is offensive to a lot of people.)

    2. Palou is with one of the best teams on the indycar grid. He won because of great skill, great driving and a great team. I don’t understand why you think his winnning makes indycar look bad.

    3. Disagree. It was obvious Palou was special when he was at Coyne. Like Grosjean, an IndyCar really suits his driving style. Not a fiery guy, just very controlled, ice like and good. The real surprise was Grosjean. A guy I thought would not do very well driving, and with the fans. He was the star of the show in many ways during the season. IndyCar has lots of exciting young talent o the grid. Can’t wait for next season.

    4. +1

      Though some would argue that it merely validates what has been a long-time suspicion about the Indycar driver pool.

      1. Nah, that’s just your own bias

    5. I entirely disagree with you. While there are drivers here and there that might not be up to snuff its no worse than F1 in that regard, just more seats available. The front of the IndyCar field is chock full of talent. Palou has always had a spark about him that never got fully recognized by the F1 ladder system establishment (these things happen). He showed brilliantly in Super Formula and his first year at Coyne. All I see is a driver that never got a shot fulfilling his potential.

      1. @seanloh he didn’t show brilliantly in super formula, he only had qualifying pace.
        From time to time someone seems to outperform, in f1 the car is the culprit, in championships like Indy it looks like a lottery.
        José, motogp is really enigmatic at the moment, Dovi thinks it is the latest michelin tyre construction, whatever the reason, bike racing was the ultimate championship when it came to rider over machine and these days you can have someone struggle all season to only then dominate a gp.

    6. @peartree @proesterchen Yeah, I think it depends on your perception. It may “look” bad to some, but I’d say it looks worse for IndyCar than it is.

      On balance, you’d have to say the driver pool is deeper in F1 right now, up and down the grid. Hamilton and Verstappen are generational talents and veterans with years of experience; and at the back, even a Mazepin is streets ahead of a Dalton Kellett. But that’s how F1 should be, considering it’s the most prestigious, expensive, and lucrative series.

      So I don’t feel that Palou or Ericsson’s success reflect particularly poorly on IndyCar at all. Palou consistently outperformed his teammates and mediocre equipment in junior formulae. In Super Formula, his first season in a top-tier series, he was a mechanical failure away from winning the championship, which would have done one better than Pierre Gasly’s SF campaign, and in lesser equipment than Gasly had. His raw qualifying pace was particularly impressive (three poles) — more so, at times, than his race pace — as was his domination in the wet at Fuji. To me, that looks like a very quick, talented driver whose results will only improve as he gains experience. Is Palou now the equal of Hamilton or Verstappen? No, but neither is Gasly.

      So IndyCar is certainly not as deep as F1, but it’s deep enough to make a Felix Rosenqvist look deeply average when you compare his results in the 10 car against Palou’s, and against O’Ward in equal equipment.

      As for Ericsson, he looked average against Leclerc, but so does Bottas against Hamilton, and Bottas still manages the occasional victory in his Merc. With Ericsson’s sponsors able to fund a seat at what is currently the top team in IndyCar, I’m not surprised to see him net a couple of wins, either.

    7. Quartararo is average?

      What’s wrong with you? :D

      1. I don’t think he follows MotoGP (and sub-categories) as much as 4 wheels racing. Either that or we weren’t watching the same sport for the last five years or so. Quartararo was dominant this season and it was rather obvious in previous years that he’s going to be one of the new stars.

        1. He doesn’t watch Indycar either. It’s easy to have opinions about something he knows nothing about.

  3. I really enjoy that RaceFans is creating rankings for series other than F1

    I generally agree with these ranked drivers except Grosjean in 6th vs. Ericsson in 7th – in my mind, Marcus really stepped up his game this season and was much more consistent

  4. Interesting and nice article, makes me look forward to 2022 in Indycar.

    Couldn’t help noticing one thing though, in Dixon’s bit:

    “He won just once this year – a dominant victory in race one at Texas – compared to four times in 2021.”

    Can’t win just one race in a season you win four.

  5. I think there is a bit of F1 bias in these rankings. You can’t have Romain Grosjean at 6 and not have Scott McLaughlin on the list when Scotty Mac beat RG to the rookie title.

    1. Grosjean did not participate in 3 of the races, and was only narrowly beaten on points by McLaughlin

      1. The context is worth considering. SM has never raced open wheelers before, and RG is a seasoned F1 multi-podium placing open wheel veteran. I am quite confident SM will finish top 7 next year.

  6. Change an untimely caution at the 500 and getting wrecked at Gateway into top 5 results and Dixon may have won the Championship. He raced very well this year. He is too low.

    Herta is too high (lacks consistency) for now. But he will get better. Clearly the team hit a setup on street and road courses that he could make the tires work on that his teammates could not and that’s props to him, but he isn’t better than Newgarden or Dixon right now.

  7. You’ve got Grosjean in there, but where is Rookie Of The Year, Scott McLaughlin? Before the “SM raced 3 more races than RG” crowd chimes in, lets remember that SM has literally never raced professional open wheelers before, and RG is a multi-podium placing formula 1 driver.

  8. I think Herta is a bit high on the list, of course he is young and talented, but he is too inconsistent at this point, O’Ward in a lesser team clinged a third in the championship.

Comments are closed.