In the round-up: Bernie Ecclestone responded to Formula 1’s criticism of his comments on racism, questioning the value of F1 chairman and CEO Chase Carey’s donation to its initiative to promote diversity in the sport.
Social media
Notable posts from Twitter, Instagram and more:
- Find more official F1 accounts to follow in the F1 Twitter Directory
Links
More motor racing links of interest:
'It's not my fault I am white': Ecclestone launches defence (Daily Mail)
"Now Chase (Carey) has put in all of $1 million — enough to get a mechanic into go-karting. Maybe he should concentrate on doing what the shareholders want."
La Formula 1 su Sky anche per le stagioni 2021 e 2022 (Sky - Italian)
Formula 1 will remain on Italian pay television channel Sky Sport in 2021 and 2022
Performance under Pressure (Hewlett Packard Enterprise)
"Hindsight is always a great thing. I wish I knew back then what I know now, I think I would have potentially won more championships but definitely just been in a much happier place and been able to enjoy the whole experience. When I won my first championship I really didn't enjoy it."
We always endeavour to credit original sources. If you have a tip for a link to feature in the next RaceFans round-up please send it in via the contact form.
Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter and
Comment of the day
Has Daniel Ricciardo let Renault down?
I can’t see there not being any awkwardness.
Ricciardo basically took on a huge paycheque and therefore a big part of Renault’s budget and committed himself, full of promises, to being part of their revival. Just over a year later, when the sniff of something “better” came along, he immediately jumped ship.
I can’t see his mechanics and engineers being particularly stoked about that. I for one lost a lot of respect for him for that, and I have far less invested in it than the Renault workforce.
@Dot_com
Happy birthday!
No RaceFans birthdays today
If you want a birthday shout-out tell us when yours is via the contact form or adding to the list here.
On this day in F1
- Happy 25th birthday to Nicholas Latifi – who was supposed to make his F1 debut as a 24-year-old…
Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter and
Broccoliface
29th June 2020, 0:03
The poison dwarf is going on a right mad one!
ruliemaulana (@ruliemaulana)
29th June 2020, 9:11
People like you are the problem.
Tony Mansell
29th June 2020, 11:13
Exactly. Criticises him for having an outmoded view then calls him a dwarf. Way to go hero
Broccoliface
29th June 2020, 23:45
I didn’t criticize him Sherlock, I just referenced the fact he’s coming out with inflammatory soundbites again.
Broccoliface
29th June 2020, 23:41
Cry more
Sensord4notbeingafanboi (@peartree)
29th June 2020, 16:30
Lewis, Bernie or Carey?
Bart
29th June 2020, 18:52
Randy.
“Don’t want no short people round here” (Short People, Randy Newman, 1977)
Short Lives Matter A Little.
@HoHum (@hohum)
29th June 2020, 0:37
Re COTD, It takes 2 to tango, Renault probably promised more than just a big paycheque, we don’t know, but if a better car and more investment in the team was part of the deal it wasn’t evident on track, and is McL really that much better?
q85
29th June 2020, 9:03
I agree, but Alonso often gets attacked for losing patience at Mclaren, despite being promised the world and being given a poor equipment. But the difference there is he stuck it out for quite a few years before finally realising it wasn’t going to happen.
NS Biker (@rekibsn)
29th June 2020, 19:24
Unless I am mistaken, Renault and DR entered into a two year contract for 2019 and 2020. At the end of this season (for what it is or might be) the contract will end. Yes, that means end for both parties.
Renault could just as easily have signed someone else to partner Ocon for 2021 and left DR high and dry.
I don’t understand the angst over DR taking the initiative and being the first of the two entities in the current contract, to make arrangements for next season. The other side is that Renault now has loads of time to decide what they want to do and who they want to do it with for 2021 and beyond.
faulty (@faulty)
30th June 2020, 0:46
Renault could call that German dude with the Dekra sponsorship, maybe he is interested.
Urvaksh (@thedoctor03)
29th June 2020, 0:38
Love the pic used here. Almost as of Carey was responding to BE!
Jere (@jerejj)
29th June 2020, 7:38
@thedoctor03 That image is from Baku 2018.
Urvaksh (@thedoctor03)
29th June 2020, 8:12
Yep, I was joking that the use of the pic for the article was very apt since it implies Carey possibly giving the “up you” sign to BE… @jerejj
Jere (@jerejj)
29th June 2020, 8:27
@thedoctor03 Yes, Indeed. I see what you mean.
RB10 (@rb10)
29th June 2020, 0:43
CNN : “The beating of members of the Indonesian National Police was carried out by Nigerian citizens,”
https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20200627234846-12-518232/dikira-razia-imigrasi-wna-nigeria-keroyok-polisi
https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=4&v=I1MZuoxJbzg&feature=emb_title
Jay Menon (@jaymenon10)
29th June 2020, 2:16
F1 cant start soon enough, hopefully we can talk about racing once again.
Jere (@jerejj)
29th June 2020, 7:38
@jaymenon10 I couldn’t agree more.
Mayrton
29th June 2020, 7:52
Hear hear
bob (@riptide)
29th June 2020, 9:48
I didn’t know we wasn’t allowed to?
Alianora La Canta (@alianora-la-canta)
30th June 2020, 9:42
@riptide It’s a lot easier to talk about F1 racing when there is some happening…
David BR (@david-br)
29th June 2020, 2:51
In all fairness to Ecclestone, his interview in the Mail is a big bucket of blubbering nonsense. Daring Carey to try banning him from Vlad’s Race was a particular highlight in the confused inner tour of his wounded ego. He should be using his spare time to practice his nappy changing skills instead (I mean, for his imminent new offspring, obviously).
Robbie (@robbie)
29th June 2020, 8:54
@david-br 😂
Fantomius (@liko41)
29th June 2020, 14:15
To be honest, Ecclestone’r remarks on racism are pretty illuminating, if you read them.
David BR (@david-br)
29th June 2020, 15:34
@liko41 Illuminating of his own attitudes, I guess you mean. I 100% endorse Hamilton’s response: Ecclestone’s remarks show why so little was done to counter racism within F1 while BE was there. The actual interview is a morass of corralled self-justification and sniping from someone F1 has thankfully now left behind. I meant what I said, he should focus on his new child, at the ripe age of 89, and enjoy these (final) years. Every time he makes a public statement, he sounds more ridiculous and just reminds everyone how good it is he’s no longer in charge.
Fantomius (@liko41)
29th June 2020, 16:36
@david-br
You are probably so keen to correct other people misprints to read and properly understand what Ecclestone had to say.
You must be one of those liberals who think freedom of speech only extends to those who agree with them.
David BR (@david-br)
29th June 2020, 16:42
@liko41 Right, and I must have misheard all his disparaging comments on democracy and his praise of dictators around the globe too.
Fantomius (@liko41)
29th June 2020, 17:24
@david-br
This has nothing to do with Ecclestone’s political views.
You may like them or not.
The point here is: could you say Ecclestone is racist?
He said he gave an opportunity to TJ Ribbs to drive one of his cars back in the seventies and that is true. In the 70s, mind you, not last week.
He employed black people on his personal staff.
He treated Hamilton fairly, same if not better than other drivers, often praising him since day one.
Hamilton has NEVER experienced racist discrimination in F1, except for a deprecable outburst in Spain in 2007.
If he has something to complain, it’s not Formula One he should put the blame on.
The rest is pure speculation.
Fantomius (@liko41)
29th June 2020, 17:37
It was actually Willy T Ribbs , who tested Brabham in 1986. So the eighties,not the seventies.
Just to get the facts straight.
David BR (@david-br)
29th June 2020, 21:47
@liko41 You’re the one who went for the ‘liberal’ and ‘freedom of speech’ defence of BE, as though he needs it, hence my reminder about Ecclestone’s adoration of states and state figures who repress both.
Alianora La Canta (@alianora-la-canta)
30th June 2020, 9:40
@liko41 The racist booing apparently doesn’t count? (Some of it has been, though definitely not all).
Fantomius (@liko41)
30th June 2020, 11:28
@david-br
I went for “freedom of speech” because you seemed to be a little appalled by the fact Bernie was asked questions.
As for his political opinions, again: not a topic here.
Fantomius (@liko41)
30th June 2020, 11:32
@alianora-la-canta
The boos Hamilton got were mainly by generic h@ters, which I had always condemned and labeled as ignorant.
But I don’t think they are moved by racism. I am from Italy and tifosi here simply h@te everyone not dressed in a red suit.
It’s not the skin color that matters to them, it’s the car color.
Deprecable, but not racist.
Alianora La Canta (@alianora-la-canta)
30th June 2020, 9:42
@david-br Wouldn’t be surprised if he was auto-barred from every track, because he’s not needed to make things run in COVID-19 setting, and it would be easy for Liberty to “forget” to reactivate his red pass post-COVID due to damaging the brand.
anon
29th June 2020, 6:26
I don’t think Bernie said anything racist. He gave his opinion.
I hope F1 is consistent with pushing for diversity. Especially when going to Abu Dhabi, Bahrain, Russia. A great chance for F1 to “educate” fans in those countries.
Johns
29th June 2020, 6:30
Looking at the Williams pic, still cant understand why the tube has a square cross section. One never sees that in nature, are we humans smarter than millions of years of evolution? I think not.
Johns
29th June 2020, 6:31
Sorry “tub” not “tube”
Gerrit
29th June 2020, 6:51
Square sections are stronger compared to a round section when force orientation is known and dispersion of those forces are important. Round sections are stronger when force orientation is unknown or not constantly in any one or more axis. Nature has made trees round as the wind can blow from any direction and thus the force orientation can be from any angle. Man is smarter than nature as it can project and predict the force orientations and make stronger square sections to suit that force.
Gerrit
29th June 2020, 7:25
Classic case of this is in a nascar/supercar chassis where box sections are used where force orientation is known (engine bay, suspension mount and the basic underlying chassis) and round tube where force orientation is random (roll cage, side intrusion protection). Triangulation of components make each stronger as does skinning and gussetting.
ColdFly (@)
29th June 2020, 8:59
Thank you Gerrit.
Who would have thought that the most interesting part of the round-up could be found in the comment section.
Follow up question: is there any example in nature where force is always from one direction and with square structures?
Gerrit
29th June 2020, 9:33
Coldfly
“is there any example in nature where force is always from one direction and with square structures?”
I don’t think so. Can remember our art teacher, 60 years ago, saying that there are no straight lines in nature. Nor are there perfect spheres.
Maybe a beehive honeycomb structure is close? Designed to hold up vertically without needing horizontal support? Interestingly man uses the honeycomb structure in the cores of composite panels.
bosyber (@bosyber)
29th June 2020, 10:07
Great comment thread here indeed, thanks Gerrit, Johns and @coldfly – I would say, maybe the elongated shapes of some bones, like in the scapula (not sure whether that’s purely force orientation) are somewhat of an example?
melanos
29th June 2020, 20:01
Your humerus midsection is pretty much a triangle
Aiii (@)
29th June 2020, 7:31
If it wasn’t Ecclestone I’d be thinking it was a joke account to not only double down on his racism, but play the “I was born white, you can’t blame me!!!” card. Yikes, Bernie, effing yikes.
Paul Duggan
29th June 2020, 8:15
Re COTD: Renault made a bad car last year. I’m pretty sure htat wasn’t on the list of promises. DR was probably not massively stoked about that, or filled with confidence about the 2020. Renault know what his goal is. They can’t really complain – much less be surprised – when he looks elsewhere because they can’t demonstrate an ability to produce a race-winning car.
ColdFly (@)
29th June 2020, 9:06
And looking at their ‘marriage’ from a different perspective: they were on a 1 year remaining deal (and no options as far as we know). Isn’t it a very noble thing to do to advise your partner of your future plans early on? It find it more worrying when the parties drag their feet and only advise they’re leaving late in the season.
bernasaurus (@bernasaurus)
29th June 2020, 9:39
Agree w/ @coldfly he’s leaving at the end of his contract, he can choose not to renew just as much as Renault can choose not to renew. Ultimately, in every contract, one of the two comes up eventually, that’s how they all end.
Stephen Crowsen (@drycrust)
29th June 2020, 19:05
I agree. Maybe Renault were a bit surprised to see Daniel declare his intentions so early, but really the onus is on Renault to have produced a race winning car. If they had then I suspect he’d have stayed with them. The problem really is if Daniel had waited the seat at McLaren would have been taken, then he’d be stuck with being at Renault for a few more years. Ultimately his goal would be to get a seat at Mercedes or Ferrari, and getting the seat at McLaren isn’t going to harm that prospect, but staying at Renault could have given the impression he was passed his best years.
minnis (@minnis)
29th June 2020, 11:28
Given the recent influx of very young drivers (leclerc, russell, albon, norris, verstappen – all making their debuts in their late teens/early twenties) Latifi must be the oldest driver to make his debut in quite a few years. Hartley is the only other one that I can think of, but he had at least been signed as a test driver about 10 years beforehand!!
BasCB (@bascb)
29th June 2020, 11:37
Ah, Bernie goes on to prove his obscureness. He used to be at least well informed – did he miss that Carey sent a million of their OWN money?
And did he miss that many many brands are currently associating with messages supporting health care workers, supporting anti racism and pro diversity moves?
Mercedes today coming out supporting their drivers’ clearly stated views, and at the same time the message F1 put out there a few days ago show that F1/Liberty actually felt the mood right with that one.
Off course these rainbows and black cars won’t bring about a huge shift. But if they are a signal of large companies seeing their customer base shift and start supporting that with their advertisement money, that could become somethign big.
So that being one of the first large international sports to put this “rainbow diversity” thing out there might help keep and attract new partners for F1 at a time when the sport really needs some kind of message it can sell (just cars with petrol hybrid engines probably won’t be cutting it in the near future that we are stepping into).
@HoHum (@hohum)
29th June 2020, 13:40
@bascb, Bernie always thought of F1 money as his own.
BasCB (@bascb)
29th June 2020, 13:44
good point there @hohum!
Derek Edwards
29th June 2020, 11:44
In Bernie’s book if you are going to spend a million the least you should get is an exemption from the government on anti-tobacco advertising legislation.
bob (@riptide)
29th June 2020, 13:36
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/motorsport/53184543 Didn’t know about this story; found it fascinating.
Fantomius (@liko41)
29th June 2020, 14:12
Bernie is absolutely right, this time, apart from his praises for Hitler and Putin.
Racism exists and the large majority of discriminated people are probably black, but that doesn’t mean blacks are always victims by default, nor that a white man can’t be discriminated against.
Hamilton may have experienced racism in his life, but he needs to stop accusing everyone around him of racism when they disagree with him or they don’t stand with him on some march in downtown London.
Ron Dennis and Bernie Ecclestone both have their pros and cons, but sure they did NOT discriminate him.
T Weiss
29th June 2020, 15:24
“that doesn’t mean blacks are always victims by default, nor that a white man can’t be discriminated against”
The two are not mutually exclusive. If a white man is discriminated against, it doesn’t mean one less black man is discriminated against. The point is that black people in the US are overwhelmingly, by orders of magnitude, more likely to die at the hands of police. How does a discriminated white man affect that or have any meaning given the scale of the issue? Remember All Lives Matter only when Black Lives Matter. Because, you know, black people are also people.
But we should expect no less from Eccelstone, he always admired fascists (Mosely anyone?). And he was never in touch with the larger business world – to companies like Liberty this is just a marketing exercise. But Bernie is an ideologue. Once he separates everyone from each other he then separates them from their money. In his world, racism is just a strategy.
Fantomius (@liko41)
29th June 2020, 16:50
The matter is far more complicated. Black men in the US are also a lot more likely to be violent. A few cops are criminals, but the vast majority is not and they work every day in difficult and dangerous environments.
Floyd himself was not by far a role model citizen. Now, does this justify brutal force on him, unnecessary violence and homicide? Of course not.
Does the cops deserve punishing? Of course they do.
But the best way to address this issue is discussing how we can guarantee to all people, especially discriminated black kids, better opportunities.
Not idolizing Floyd.
Not treating white people as bad by default.
Not accusing whoever disagree with you of being racist.
Hamilton is a privileged human being and he seems to forget it quite often.
Aapje (@aapje)
30th June 2020, 9:50
@T Weiss
The disparity between men and women is even greater. Are men being discriminated against? Or is this acceptable because men are more often criminal?
Black Americans are far more often criminal than white Americans. Isn’t the logical consequence that they deal with the police more often?
Note that black Americans are equally likely to die per police encounter. They do have more police encounters.
Harold wilson
30th June 2020, 1:35
You clearly don’t see the problem if you can on the one hand say praising Putin & Hitler was wrong, but he is right with everything else.
mirko710
29th June 2020, 15:36
No one is commenting Supercars? It was very exciting weekend.
5 sets of tyres for the weekend. Not enough for a full tilt for 3 races, even sprints. So there was some strategy when to use fresh rubber, when to put only 2 or 3 tyres at a pit stop.
‘Smaller’ teams had a chance
Velocityboy (@velocityboy)
29th June 2020, 16:22
Someone really needs to put Mumm-ra back into his crypt. I can see why reporters go to him, as he’s interview gold but enough of his mumblings already.
Radoye
29th June 2020, 16:38
Bernie is certainly entitled to his opinion, however wrong it may be.
But, if Bernie wants to criticize Carey for donating $1M because that amount doesn’t go far enough, that’s still $1M more than Bernie put up. Talk is cheap.
Alianora La Canta (@alianora-la-canta)
30th June 2020, 9:34
@Radoye While we know Bernie doesn’t believe in the cause and therefore won’t have donated a cent, Bernie also wouldn’t have told us how much he donated if he had done so.
Radoye
30th June 2020, 13:57
Maybe he would tell us – such donations are tax deductible, you know.
socksolid (@socksolid)
29th June 2020, 22:50
As far as cotd goes I think it is a bit naive to think that it would be the mechanics to worry about. It is the top level management who can make things awkward. But the guys and gals doing work on the car, the engineers at races and at factory. They know what it is. All of them are just contracted employees and when better things come they move. There is no personal feelings like there might be at higher levels where it also about personal connections and relationships – things you say or leave unsaid. And if the top level management is being difficult I’d expect the mechanics and engineers to sympathise with ricciardo. Not turn against him. Unless it is poisoned atmosphere…
Dani B. Molina (@esmiz)
29th June 2020, 23:33
About the COTD:
If I recall correctly, the last time a Renault driver announced he was leaving for McLaren, a year before leaving, Renault and the driver won the constructors and the drivers championship.
It’s not exactly the same situation, in 2006 both were winning teams and now both are midfield teams, but I think that for Ricciardo and Renault, it’s better to work well this year. Awkwardness is going to depend on the results
Alianora La Canta (@alianora-la-canta)
30th June 2020, 9:33
Chase’s company helped create the scheme to which he donated. It would have been more puzzling had he not done so. Also, shareholders want companies to respond to their circumstances, especially when they are as heavy as currently is the case.
(I do wonder, however, if Bernie is critical because Chase publicised the size of the donation. Bernie donated to charities quite a bit to various causes over the years, but he made a point of never talking about the size of donations – partly because he felt that stating the donated amount was bragging, partly because of vulnerability to accusations of not doing the “right” size of donation for the cause).