F1

So Who`s Better… Hamilton or Alonso?

Viewing 11 posts - 16 through 26 (of 26 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #158184
    sbl on tour
    Participant

    alonso hamilton….but whose better…theres only one way to find out……FIGHT!

    H HILL tv burp

    #158185
    colinf
    Participant

    “I agree with what skodarap said about Lewis being better when he has a competitive team mate, seems to push him more and I think being team mates with Button will be good for him.”

    Aside from Alonso, Hamilton has never really had a competitive team mate. It is my suspicion that there were more problems at McLaren than Alonso has openly admitted which would explain the closeness of their results.

    Button is the first reasonably competitive post-Alonso team mate that Hamilton has had, and he struggled to come out ahead on points against him. I think that is telling.

    #158186
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Thanks guys good debate here and nice to read ALL of your comments.Just want to respond to a few:

    Dan Thorn and Steph,

    Hamilton was not scared off the road by Alonso he made a mistake like everyone else does from time to time.Hope you havent watched Jose Lorca`s(Fernando-Fan-Boy who creates multiple IDs on BBC 606 Forum) vids:

    Massa Double Overtake on Hamilton and Webber

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nmlPD1qNptw

    Hamilton: “The Drive Of My Life”

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fKz1uESrnzs

    Hamilton SCARED of Fernando Alonso

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P_CC4FNsLb8

    Photographer captures Hamilton crying

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vfTRXVd1eas

    These are some of the vids he makes.Gives Alonsos fans a bad name.

    #158187
    Victor.
    Participant

    Put them in the same car and we’ll find out. Oh wait…

    #158188
    colinf
    Participant

    I think FOM should have an official kart race at the end of the season with all the drivers in spec karts.

    #158189
    Stephen Jones
    Participant

    cage-match, fight to the death.. that’s the only way i can separate them..

    and in that case i’m tipping alonso cause he looks like a badass.. but i’m sure hamilton can bite

    #158190
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @John I didn’t mean scared of Alonso or any disrespect. Hamilton admitted himself that when it’s Alonso he’s racing he gets a bit more tense and that puts pressure on him and Hamilton isn’t the best under pressure. I don’t mean he’s scared of Alonso just that the pressure may at times mean he’s more likely to make mistakes. He was perfect at Indianapolis 07 though so he’s shown he can cope fine with it when he wants to.

    I’ve never even heard of the fan of Fernando and I don’t read the BBC forum lol.

    #158191
    Dan Thorn
    Participant

    Same here. Korea was more unfortunate as the conditions were tricky but he was definately rattled by Fernando at Brazil – Alonso feinted a move and Hamilton went wide. Of course he isn’t affected all the time – As Steph said Indy ’07, also Canada 2010 he was brilliant.

    Performing under pressure is definately the main thing Hamilton needs to improve, particularly towards the end of a season. He needs to learn the value of simply finishing races rather than going for glory, but then arguably he wouldn’t be the driver he is and have the amount of fans he does.

    I don’t read 606 either, it’s full of fanboys. (This is the only forum I get involved in :P)

    #158192
    Icthyes
    Participant

    I think one day Hamilton will be more successful than Alonso. But they have different approaches that are hard to compare.

    Alonso will work methodically behind the scenes, get into the car and drive it like a metronome. He will make good strategy calls and adapt to the race unfolding.

    Hamilton on the other hand will take a slightly more passive role in setting up the car, just as likely to take a gamble but rather not on his own initiative like Alonso. Then he will get into the car and get it to do what he wants, even if he has to fight tooth and nail. He hasn’t developed his race brain yet but he is a fantastic opportunist, Monza 2010 aside.

    Alonso too is no stranger to being rattled. Valencia and Silverstone showed that vividly. Contrary to a lot of opinion I see, I think Hamilton’s work needs to be done less in this area and more in general defensive driving. Monza aside, pressure is something he’s getting a hold onto, but in keeping faster cars behind he needs a bit more skill, like Alonso has.

    #158195
    rabbit
    Participant
    #158196
    Adam Tate
    Participant

    To me it boils down to just this: Hamilton is more talented than Alonso, but Alonso is a smarter racer than Hamilton. In the end these nearly offset each other and leave the two about equal with one another, much the way they finished the 07 season, in a dead heat.

Viewing 11 posts - 16 through 26 (of 26 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.