MCG

Fully agree, impossible to make it 100% even regardless of circumstance, but i thing there should be a little more freedom for the penalty to be malleable to keep it in kilter with the events within the season to […]

I can’t see there being much racing in future if the driver has to be ahead before the corner, i.e. can’t use the corner to his advantage as part of an overtake maneuver.

@fluxsource – no the “predominantly at fault” I believe is correct, as it was at Silverstone, it is just the degree of punishment that is out of kilter (I my opionion), they could go with 1.2.3 place ETC, it rea […]

I think you mis-understand what Alonso was saying

A little confusing as you are sort of agreeing that Alonso is right and it is a racing incident, but then saying the penalty is also right…which is it? racing incidents don’t get penalised.

I semi agree, I think a 3 place penalty is too much when compared to what Lewis got at Silverstone, they just don’t add up to the same for the same. I think that is the biggest issue, the current rules around […]

I think you are mis-understand what Alonso was saying.

100% with you mate. Both racing incidents, unlucky for 1 or 2, but still just a racing incidents.

Yep, as was Silverstone. it is a dangerous, competitive sport and this will happen.

Exactly
Ham at fault at Silverstone
Max at fault here
Exactly the same fault on each of them
Completely different sanctions, balanced very much in the favor of one.

I am a Max fan, I don’t believe there is any argument that this one is on Max. The issue I believe is that the punishment is way out of kilter with similar incidents. This sanction is very likely to have a big […]

Exactly, different penalties for different drivers

I don’t really get how anyone can compare this to Silverstone.
Silverstone was an extreme high speed incident and as such very dangerous. Lewis wasn’t even close to alongside, his front wheel was in line with […]

I 100% believe George will take more points from Lewis than Valtteri did, this will make it more difficult for Lewis to dominate and the relationship between drivers will sour as it did with Nico. This time Lewis […]

Of coarse he is Lewis’s favorite ever team mate. Lewis has always had great relationships with Team Mates that didn’t challenge him

Maybe change the points system, N points for quali position and N points for race position.

Personally i think the outcome was perfectly reasonable under the circumstances, Teams got rewarded for hard work in dangerous conditions, it would have been a very expensive weekend for the Teams and some did […]

The point being made is the relative degree of punishment, not if or if not, sorry you missed the subtle difference.

Folks, why don’t we just all agree that the whole F1 Circus is exactly that, a Circus. They can allow one person to stand up for what he chooses, but the others must not, unless it is what they are told to stand […]

Funny, but stupid