Harry commented on the post, Red Bull announce plans for 1,100bhp hypercar with £5 million price tag 1 month, 1 week ago
@dbradock “Building the RB17 will create over 100 new jobs at its factory, Red Bull said”
Harry commented on the post, Vettel tells media to 'give Mick Schumacher a break' after latest crash 2 months, 1 week ago
Brundle said in commentary that the new regulations stipulated that the cars should split at that point more easily. First I’d heard of it, and if true I’m not sure what the rationale is behind that. I would have […]
Harry commented on the post, Vandoorne beats Evans to take Monaco EPrix win and championship lead 3 months, 1 week ago
@chrispeetz @wsrgo The race was great but the direction/coverage was the worst I have ever seen, in any racing category. There was one point where there were three cars abreast in the midfield (how often does that […]
Harry commented on the post, Fifth behind Ferrari and Red Bull "a good target" for Alfa Romeo – Bottas 4 months ago
@mashiat
+1Harry commented on the post, Coroner rules Mosley took own life after terminal cancer diagnosis 4 months, 1 week ago
forgot to @eljueta
Harry commented on the post, Coroner rules Mosley took own life after terminal cancer diagnosis 4 months, 1 week ago
I took it that you meant that you don’t see why it’s a “hot topic” in so many countries – i.e. why there’s fuss and controversy over something where you feel the “correct” solution is self-evident. In that case, […]
Harry commented on the post, FIA publishes Abu Dhabi report, confirms Masi made errors but states result will stand 4 months, 3 weeks ago
@nanotech it’s free to register an account, which makes it all the more curious why some people who come year after year haven’t done so.
Harry commented on the post, Verstappen quickest from Leclerc by less than a tenth in second practice 4 months, 3 weeks ago
People have been overrating Mercedes’ PU (and underrating their chassis) for at least five years. Further, Mercedes did express concern about the move to E10 fuel and the negative impact that was going to have on […]
Harry commented on the post, Wittich simplifies Bahrain track limits rules in first event as F1 race director 4 months, 3 weeks ago
@warheart “Maybe they just need to change ‘any white lines’ to ‘all white lines’ ”
Ha! Good catch!Harry commented on the post, FIA changes F1 rule on lapped cars overtaking Safety Car after Abu Dhabi row 4 months, 3 weeks ago
@fluxsource You are not correct that the “some” interpretation logically forces the “all” interpretation by contradiction. You are correct however that it would mean that the rulebook simply left out how the cars […]
Harry commented on the post, FIA changes F1 rule on lapped cars overtaking Safety Car after Abu Dhabi row 4 months, 3 weeks ago
@drmouse, @fluxsource, @david-br, you say that we can “tell by the context” that what the rule really meant was “all”, and some have suggested that we can just “expand” the text a little to make that even clearer […]
Harry commented on the post, FIA changes F1 rule on lapped cars overtaking Safety Car after Abu Dhabi row 4 months, 3 weeks ago
@drmouse Perhaps it is not clear that I mostly agree with you about context and intended meaning. What I’m saying is that relying on context creates multiple possible interpretations and is a recipe for disaster […]
Harry commented on the post, FIA changes F1 rule on lapped cars overtaking Safety Car after Abu Dhabi row 4 months, 3 weeks ago
@fluxsource I think what perplexes me is why people are so vehemently opposed to a strict logical interpretation of the rule book. Your correct answer to my question demonstrates that indeed, on a strict logical […]
Harry commented on the post, FIA changes F1 rule on lapped cars overtaking Safety Car after Abu Dhabi row 4 months, 3 weeks ago
@fluxsource @drmous @david-br just wondering if you could answer me this question:
Did any lapped cars pass the Safety Car at the end of the 2021 Abu Dhabi Grand Prix?
Harry commented on the post, FIA changes F1 rule on lapped cars overtaking Safety Car after Abu Dhabi row 4 months, 3 weeks ago
@drmouse I think we’ll have to just agree to disagree. What you are saying is that, as written, the rules did not strictly by the rules of logic mean what they intended to mean, and we instead have to invoke […]
Harry commented on the post, FIA changes F1 rule on lapped cars overtaking Safety Car after Abu Dhabi row 4 months, 3 weeks ago
@fluxsource it would appear that my point is not well made. Sorry about that. I’m just saying that it’s really, really important that the words “any” and “all” do actually have different meanings when it comes to […]
Harry commented on the post, FIA changes F1 rule on lapped cars overtaking Safety Car after Abu Dhabi row 4 months, 3 weeks ago
@david-br I see what you did there, assuming that that was deliberate! I wouldn’t say that programming languages are relevant in all contexts, but in this case programming languages are relevant/helpful due to the […]
Harry commented on the post, FIA changes F1 rule on lapped cars overtaking Safety Car after Abu Dhabi row 4 months, 3 weeks ago
Programming languages are not irrelevant. Those that incorporate the keywords/functions/operators “any” and “all” demonstrate very succinctly the clear and dramatic difference between the meaning of the two […]
Harry commented on the post, FIA changes F1 rule on lapped cars overtaking Safety Car after Abu Dhabi row 4 months, 3 weeks ago
No. “Any” does not mean “All”. If it did, many programming languages would cease to function.
For me, the issue was not with the fact that only some cars were let through. The bigger issue was that the rules very […]Harry commented on the post, Hamilton: People who say Mercedes are talking ourselves down are in for a surprise 4 months, 4 weeks ago
Ah yes, because as we all know, Mercedes have come in 1 & 2 in every race in the last seven years. At least, if you were someone who never watched F1, that’s what you would think if just went by this “Hamilton’s […]
- Load More