Pierre Gasly, Alpine, Shanghai International Circuit, 2024

“You need to be more on it”: 12 unheard radio exchanges from the Chinese GP

Formula 1

Posted on

| Written by

Un-broadcast radio messages from last weekend’s Chinese Grand Prix reveal how Aston Martin blamed Carlos Sainz Jnr for the collision between Lance Stroll and Daniel Ricciardo, how Haas played a strategic masterstroke at the start, why Pierre Gasly was frustrated with his team’s tactics and more.

Plus, why did it take so long for the race to restart following the two Safety Car periods, and how Zhou Guanyu was unaware Formula 1 planned a special post-race celebration for him.

Hulkenberg’s early stop

Whoever was first into the pits stood to claim an advantage by getting onto fresher tyres before their rivals. Haas made sure Nico Hulkenberg pulled it off with a very late call for him to pit – so late, in fact, he admitted he anticipated it.

Lap: 8/56 HUL: 1’49.064
GannonBox now, Nico, box now.
HulkenbergFucking hell! Bit late. I just second-guessed there, that was too late.

“We’re racing Ferrari, no?”

Lando Norris, McLaren, Shanghai International Circuit, 2024
McLaren were surprised by their pace in Shanghai

Early in the race, McLaren discovered to their surprise their pace was strong compared to rivals Ferrari. Lando Norris encouraged his team to forget about covering off rivals such as Fernando Alonso and George Russell and focus on out-running the Ferrari pair. It paid off.

Lap: 13/56 NOR: 1’41.805
NorrisYeah pace is good. The pace seems strong. Let’s maximise our race. Let’s not get too hung up on the people who boxed. We’re in a good position.
JosephLando we agree the pace looks good. Last lap Leclerc did a 41.9, Sainz did a 42.6, we think we’re racing them.
Lap: 16/56 NOR: 1’41.795
JosephLando just a bit of a question for you. Alonso’s 27.3, If we pitted ahead of him and gave them free air Ferraris might just extend, I’m not sure. Or we’d have to come up behind Alonso and pass him later. Alonso on a hard tyre.
Lap: 17/56 NOR: 1’41.700
NorrisWe’re racing Ferrari, no?
JosephWe understand that. Just trying to think how best to beat them. In terms of clean air ahead of Alonso or extend similar to them?
NorrisI think extend with them.
JosephUnderstood.
Lap: 20/56 NOR: 1’42.167
JosephLando, question: How are the tyres? Gap to Alonso 24.4, Russell 27.1. Would you be happy behind one car? Would you be happy behind two cars?
NorrisI think I’d overtake both.
JosephUnderstood. And tyre update please.

When Valtteri Bottas came to a stop, Norris was braced to pit if a Virtual Safety Car or Safety Car period began. To his frustration, the VSC was called moments after he passed the pit lane entrance.

To his relief, the VSC period continued for over a lap, and he was able to pit without losing time to the Ferraris.

Lap: 21/56 NOR: 1’43.566
NorrisYeah, they’re hanging on. I mean, they’re getting a little bit worse, but obviously not bad.
JosephYellow flags from here to turn 11. Bottas has stopped. Both Safety Car windows are open, please confirm.
NorrisYeah, there’s debris on-track. They need to do the Safety Car or VSC. A lot of debris on-track.
NorrisNorris passes the pit lane entrance and the Virtual Safety Car is deployed.
Fucking joking me.
JosephTell me about it.
Lap: 22/56 NOR: 2’18.646
NorrisOh, I fucking knew it.
NorrisBox, correct?
JosephYes.
NorrisI think we’ve got to box anyway, yeah?

Leclerc queries Alonso

Several drivers darted into the pits to change tyres when the VSC period began, including Leclerc. He was surprised to emerge from the pits slightly behind Fernando Alonso, who got to the crucial Safety Car Line Two before him. Leclerc urged his team to check Alonso had followed the rules, and as no action was taken, it appears he did.

Lap: 21/56 LEC: 1’51.969
Marcos PadrosVirtual Safety Car deployed
Box now. Box now. Box, box. And going for hard. Will be close with Alonso, pit exit. Brake balance minus one. Close with Alonso at pit exit.
Lap: 22/56 LEC: 2’30.205
LeclercAlonso gets ahead of him
Fuck.
Marcos PadrosSo Alonso has a 10-lap used hard.
LeclercLet’s check if he was positive at the line, because now he’s over my delta.
Marcos PadrosCopy that.
LeclercHow fast will be the VSC?

Gasly’s Hamilton frustration

Another close call occured at the pit exit line between Lewis Hamilton and Pierre Gasly. After examining footage of the moment the pair reached the line, Alpine told their driver they had to let Hamilton by. Gasly was unimpressed:

Lap: 21/56 HAM: 2’02.779, GAS: 2’03.250
Hamilton…dropping off.GaslyUnder Virtual Safety Car conditions.
Struggling understeer apex turn three and apex turn nine. Still some bouncing turn eight.
BonningtonSo VSC. VSC. Keep the delta positive.HowardOkay, copy that. So we’re going to stay out Pierre. We’ll stay out unless this goes real.
HamiltonSomething’s wrong, mate. The tyres are dead, already.
BonningtonYep, copy Lewis. We’ve certainly given them a hard time.
HamiltonI’m about to lose a place to the car behind.
BonningtonOkay, let us know what you want on flap if we do come in.
BonningtonOkay Lewis, so we’ll box, box. Let us know on flap.
Lap: 22/56 HAM: 2’29.397, GAS: 2’14.094
BonningtonHamilton leaves the pits
So you’re going to have Gasly and Magnussen with you.
HowardGasly passes the pit lane entrance, Hamilton appears alongside him and they reach the Safety Car Line Two together
So suggest a bit more management in eight to help turn nine.
BonningtonHamilton emerges ahead of Gasly
So you were ahead. And we’ll go strat mode ‘one’. So, Lewis, we’ll need to bring these tyres in nice and steady when this gets going again. So it’s going to be management turns seven and eight and the lift-and-coast does look efficient.
GaslyI don’t know if I was ahead. Let me know if I was ahead of the Mercedes.
HamiltonHamilton is overtaken by Gasly under VSC at turn seven
I’ve just been overtaken. He just overtook me.
HowardOkay we’ll look.
BonningtonWe believe you should have the position. Will clarify.GaslyGuys, you need to be more on it. You should have told me that Lewis was arriving.
HamiltonEither way, he’s just overtaken me on the outside.HowardCopy that mate, we’re looking at it.
BonningtonAs Gasly slows on the exit of turn ten to allow Hamilton to re-pass
So according to our systems, you crossed the Safety Car 2 line first, so it should be your position.
GaslyLet me know if I was ahead. I think I passed the line in front.
HowardAnd Pierre we need to let Hamilton by, let Hamilton through.
GaslyYeah, we should have been ahead for sure. I need you guys to be more on it for this kind of situation. I could have pushed more.
HowardCopy mate. Just keep an eye on your delta.

Gasly could console himself with the fact Alpine had at least advised him what to do. In another similar incident, Williams failed to tell Logan Sargeant he needed to let Nico Hulkenberg overtake him, and he ended up collecting a 10-second time penalty.

“It was maybe Sainz”

Daniel Ricciardo, RB, Shanghai International Circuit, 2024
Blame flew in all directions after Stroll slammed into the rear of Ricciardo

At the end of the subsequent Safety Car period, the field bunched up approaching turn 14, and Lance Stroll clattered into the back of Daniel Ricciardo. He struck the RB with enough force to send it into the McLaren of Oscar Piastri in front of them.

Stroll and Ricciardo blamed each other, but the stewards held the Aston Martin driver responsible. He was given a penalty, but at the end of the race Stroll’s race engineer suggested Carlos Sainz Jnr had been at fault.

Lap: 26/56 STR: 2’35.395, RIC: 2’32.359
VizardJust reminder Lance it’s no overtaking until the control line.RicciardoYeah I got hit. Yeah I got fucking it.
StrollThis idiot just slammed on the brake, check wing damage.
Lap: 27/56 STR: 3’41.520, RIC: 1’54.803
StrollStroll arrives in the pit lane.
Replace the wing.
HamelinCopy. We’re checking, we’re checking. Keep us posted on the car.
RicciardoKeep checking but something’s definitely got some damage.
HamelinCopy that we can’t see anything on data currently. We’ll keep checking, can’t see anything on data.
RicciardoThe Haas also passed before the Safety Car line.
HamelinConfirmed. Data That okay so far. Keep the head down.
RicciardoYeah I’ll keep pushing but something’s definitely up.
HamelinConfirmed we have small damage we are down on load. Mode seven. Safety Car, Safety Car.
RicciardoShould I box? Let me know.
HamelinStay out. Stay out. Okay Daniel we do have damage on the floor. We’re assessing the balance was much, but we are down on load. We are assessing numbers.
Lap: 35/56 STR: 1’45.678
VizardOkay Lance so we’ve been given a 10-second penalty for the incident under the safety car. We’d like to box this lap and serve it. So box this lap, it’ll be a 10-second penalty.
StrollUnbelievable, man. Such a joke.
Chequered flag
VizardOkay, that’s the chequered flag. Unlucky there, mate. That was going really well to start with. First two stints were going good until that safety car. So for info that was a big concertina, caught a few out, I think it was maybe Sainz just caused that down the front somewhere.
StrollYeah. So ridiculous, man. That the whole train in front of me just stopped. Twice, even down the main straight there was like someone that braked. And then again at the hairpin.
VizardYeah, no, we saw it definitely wasn’t you. It was kind of chaos, wasn’t it? Not very good driving there for them.

Oblivious Piastri

Oscar Piastri, McLaren, Shanghai International Circuit, 2024
Piastri didn’t know he’d been hit until his team told him

Meanwhile Piastri was unaware he’d been hit, until he experienced the degraded handling of his McLaren resulting from his damaged diffuser.

Lap: 29/56 PIA: 2’25.655
StallardSo Oscar we see some damage from the restart contact. We have lost… equivalent to three two four holes of front wing flap. We’re going to need to manage that with the driving and the toys.
Lap: 30/56 PIA: 2’21.071
PiastriCopy. I don’t remember having any contact but okay.
StallardSo there was contact with Ricciardo, who touched the back of our car in 14, and we have damage at the rear there.
PiastriAh, okay.
StallardBut give us an update on the balance once you get into some proper laps.
PiastriSo do I have three holes less front wing now or more?
StallardEquivalent to more.
StallardSo, Oscar, we can confirm from pictures we do have diffuser damage so the balance will be more forwards.

“I’m passing him anyway”

Nico Hulkenberg, Haas, Shanghai International Circuit, 2024
Ricciardo landed himself in trouble by overtaking Hulkenberg under Safety Car conditions

Ricciardo’s frustration over the Stroll incident got the better of him. Hulkenberg had passed him while contact was made, and behind the Safety Car he chose to re-pass the Haas driver without waiting for his team to advise him.

This was a costly mistake. The stewards penalised Ricciardo for overtaking under the Safety Car, and he will have a three-place driver penalty at the Miami Grand Prix.

Lap: 28/56 RIC: 2’26.589
RicciardoWhat a fucking arsehole, man. Yeah, let me pass Hulkenberg yeah?
HamelinStand by, I’ll keep you posted. Ricciardo passes Hulkenberg
Mode 14.
RicciardoYeah I’m passing him anyway. It’s my position.
HamelinCopy Daniel.
RicciardoAnd I’m assuming if we box, it’s not repairable.
HamelinIt’s floor damage, so we keep assessing. I’ll keep you posted.
Okay Daniel so we have a rearward balance and we are down on load. We keep assessing. For now keep your head down and see what we can do to the end.
RicciardoUnderstood. There’s still shit all over the track before last corner, before the hairpin, turn 11.

RB tried to keep Ricciardo in the race, but to his obvious disappointment he was forced to retire. He remains yet to score a point this year, and had been ninth before Stroll hit him.

Lap: 29/56 RIC: 2’25.366
HamelinCopy.
RicciardoThey also didn’t clean turn 11, there’s grass all over the track.
HamelinWe have a double yellow between tun, 14 and 15. Okay Daniel so we’ll have to see where we are with balance when we restart. Then will assess switches required. It’s very hard to pre-empt what we’re going to get now.
RicciardoYeah, I already felt, a lot of understeer turning right.
HamelinPlease repeat, Daniel.
RicciardoAlready on that half a lap, a lot of understeer, especially starting right.
HamelinOkay. Double yellow is gone between 14 and 16. Okay Daniel you can look at the dash. Front tyres are still going down, but same for everyone. Reminder we’re on medium. Most of the other cars are on hard. We have Alonso ahead of you on soft. We can consider going down on diff entry for restart if you think understeer will be the main issue.
Lap: 30/56 RIC: 2’21.054
RicciardoUnderstood. I think, er…
HamelinYeah, it will be difficult, mate. I share your frustration.
HamelinMode 11, please. Okay the double yellow is gone again between 14 and 16. And you’re doing good with your brakes, you’re staying in a good place. And we’ve reported turn 11.
Lap: 31/56 RIC: 2’23.797
HamelinAnd Safety Car in this lap. And heads-up, Daniel: Also the cars around you have damage. I’ve just seen Piastri has floor damage. Charge on, mode three in the background. We’ll try to do what we can and you know the plan for end of race.
HamelinOkay offset is good. And it will be charge off before the last corner, racing from the line.
Lap: 32/56 RIC: 1’44.075
RicciardoRestart
I got no fucking rear on exits.
HamelinMode seven. Copy that.
Lap: 33/56 RIC: 1’55.415
HamelinDRS enabled. I’ll keep you posted.
HamelinOkay Daniel that will be box, box.
RicciardoUnderstood.
HamelinOkay Daniel there is too much damage. Too much damage. We retire the car. We have far too much damage now. Box, box.
RicciardoUnderstood.
Lap: 34/56 RIC:
HamelinOkay if you can stop in front of the garage and switch off, please. Yeah I have no words, Daniel. Pace was very strong there before the Safety Car.
RicciardoYeah, I could go off but I’ll save it.
HamelinYeah, he’s got a penalty, but obviously it doesn’t help us.

Debris delay

Some driver queried why it took so long for the race to restart after the two interruptions. On each occasion it was because other drivers had reported debris on the track:

Lap: 23/56 ALO: 2’17.153, HUL: 2’17.671
AlonsoWho benefits from this? Leclerc, Norris?
CroninYeah. So Leclerc, Norris. Russell and Piastri aame as us. Sainz same as us. It’s okay for us the moment, it’s all okay.
CroninOkay so this is a Safety Car.
AlonsoThe car is stuck there? They need maybe the red flag or no?
CroninFernando we are boxing this lap.
AlonsoCopy.
Lap: 25/56 ALO: 2’15.201, HUL: 1’59.529
CroninWe’ve got the track clear message.
AlonsoAt turn 16
There is a lot of grass the inside of turn 11. Maybe they can do something.
Lap: 26/56 ALO: 2’31.709, HUL: 2’27.733
CroninUnderstood Fernando so a lot of grass turn 11.
AlonsoWe cannot overtake until… finish line?
CroninYeah finish line, exactly.

Alonso had good reason to want the Safety Car to stay out longer as he had switched to the soft tyres while others were on hards. But he wasn’t the only driver drawing race control’s attention to debris on the track:

Lap: 27/56 ALO: 1’50.392, HUL: 1’54.261
GannonStroll crashes into Ricciardo ahead of Hulkenberg
Mode push, mode push. Safety Car. Safety Car. Stay out. Positive delta time and stay out, Nio.
HulkenbergThat was super-weird. I think the Aston crashed into an AlphaTauri. A bit confusing.
GannonYes, that is exactly what happened.
Lap: 28/56 ALO: 2’30.078, HUL: 2’29.564
HulkenbergThere is part here between 14 and 15. Some carbon part in the middle of the straight.
GannonCopy that, we’ll report it. So it’s two times past the line. So you no delta the safety car has leader Verstappen. So it is now a yellow for that debris that you reported. And that debris has been cleared. Still talking about the Ricciardo situation?
Lap: 29/56 ALO: 2’25.818, HUL: 2’25.148
HulkenbergSo that debris is still there.
Lap: 30/56 ALO: 2’22.100, HUL: 2’21.361
GannonCopy, we’ll report it again. So we’re still waiting for resolution on the Ricciardo thing, but if it doesn’t get swapped back around, in any case, he has some damage and he has older mediums.

Leclerc’s misunderstanding

Charles Leclerc, Sergio Perez
Leclerc couldn’t make sense of his race engineer’s message

Towards the end of the race, Leclerc was puzzled by a message from his race engineer:

Lap: 55/56 LEC: 1’40.882
Marcos PadrosAnd try original line turns seven-eight for comparison.
LeclercWhat?
Marcos PadrosTry original line turn, seven and eight.
LeclercI don’t understand you. How is that a line? What the hell is that?
Marcos PadrosOriginal line – like the beginning of the race.
Marcos PadrosSlippery track reported where you are for debris, we believe right-hand side.
LeclercOriginal line, you said?
Marcos PadrosOriginal, yes.
LeclercWhat the hell does that mean?
Lap: 56/56 LEC: 1’40.568
Marcos PadrosJust forget it, it’s last lap.
Chequered flag
LeclercWe were much slower than McLaren today. I mean, there was nothing I could have done more at turn one-two-three. For me it has been an enigma. I think we’ll have to look into it because I’ve tried literally everything.
Marcos PadrosYeah copy that. Plenty to analyse in it.

Norris’ pit error

Lando Norris, McLaren, Shanghai International Circuit, 2024
Norris slipped up after taking the chequered flag

Having finished in the top three, Norris was supposed to park on the pit straight, but drove into the pits instead. His team discouraged him from reversing back onto the track. In a series of messages which weren’t broadcast, Norris ribbed his race engineer about the error.

Chequered flag
JosephLando, driver of the day.
NorrisOh my God! Thank you so much. I didn’t know I had so many Chinese supporters, but it’s incredible. So thank you very much. Oh I’ll have to say it, but happy birthday mum for yesterday. I guess this one was for you. Love you, mum.
NorrisNorris begins driving into the pit lane entrance, then stops, wondering if he’s supposed to park on the grid.
Where do I, do I go into the pit lane or not? Why’ve you not told me this? Everyone’s gone onto the grid.
JosephApologies, should have gone through the grid, my bad.
NorrisOkay.
JosephSo I suggest stopping in front of the FIA garage, and then we can walk out to the grid.
NorrisI’ve got this I think.
JosephLando if you can keep moving please. Do not reverse, mate, do not reverse, just drive forwards.
NorrisI didn’t reverse.
JosephI see what you did.
NorrisWinding each other up
Yes, Will, should be on the grid.
JosephMy bad. Too busy…
NorrisConcentrate, Will, concentrate. Breathe, Will.
JosephAll right, all right.

Gasly’s concern

A mechanic was knocked over during one of Pierre Gasly’s pit stops when he was incorrectly told to leave too soon. After taking the chequered flag, Gasly checked up on his condition:

Chequered flag
GaslyHow’s the mechanic?
HowardYep. Everyone here is all good.
GaslyOkay.
HowardYep. No injuries.
GaslyAll right.
HowardYeah. Thanks for your concern.
GaslyI just got to review because I went at the green and then it went red again. But glad he’s fine.
HowardYeah, we’ll give it a good look. Thanks, buddy.

Zhou unaware of post-race plan

Zhou Guanyu, Sauber, Shanghai International Circuit, 2024
Zhou got to celebrate with his fans after finishing 14th

For Zhou’s home race, Formula 1 arranged a special celebration to take place after he took the chequered flag. Although it was mentioned in the pre-race notes, it came as a surprise to the local racer, who emerged from his car on the start/finish straight to the cheers of the crowd:

Chequered flag
BenisiWe finish P14, Zhou, P14.
ZhouYeah. The first stint was the tough one. I just didn’t really have the grip.
BenisiLast one you did a good job there.
Alunni BraviTough race but enjoy this moment in front of your fans. A special moment for you, your family. We will have other opportunities to score points, but today’s your day, Zhou.
ZhouYeah thanks. Yeah it’s been amazing so far. ‘course love to be in the points but it’s been very special to be here.
Alunni BraviWe’ll keep fighting together Zhou, we’ll keep fighting.
ZhouCome to the garage?
BenisiGo to the finish line, Zhou. Go to the finish line.
BenisiZhou, continue on track, go to the start-finish line and enjoy this moment, man.
ZhouOkay, thank you man.
BenisiAnd full switch off procedure there.
ZhouThanks guys. Thanks also the mechanics, being a more consistent pit stop. Let’s keep working.

Author information

Keith Collantine
Lifelong motor sport fan Keith set up RaceFans in 2005 - when it was originally called F1 Fanatic. Having previously worked as a motoring...

Got a potential story, tip or enquiry? Find out more about RaceFans and contact us here.

9 comments on ““You need to be more on it”: 12 unheard radio exchanges from the Chinese GP”

  1. I’m surprised no one in the Sauber team had informed him beforehand about the post-race procedure document, which informs in both text & visualization form where the top 3 & remaining finishers should park cars.

    1. notagrumpyfan
      28th April 2024, 7:38

      Why worry about that during the race?

      Race engineers willing (pun intended) they tell you after the race what to do.

      1. Not during but before.

  2. Ahhh right – I get it now.
    Sainz used his brakes.
    Then all the other drivers behind him used their brakes so that they wouldn’t crash into the car in front of them.
    And that is why Lance crashed into the car in front of him.

    Poor Lance. I wonder why people are so mean about him.

    1. Same with roadway rules.
      Do not crash into the car in front of your car.
      Even if they are braking or stopping.
      Does not apply to Lance or even his team in F1.

      1. Yep, when you crash into the car ahead (unless you can somehow prove that car was really doing something malign) you can even get a fine for not keeping your distance / misjudging the circumstances (if it’s wet or freezing) and will be liable for damages to the other cars.

        But it wasn’t Sainz, it was Alonso overkooking his softs there, wasn’t it?

        1. Of course. Again.

          Reply moderated
        2. @bascb – I saw a wreck today when a pickup truck mashed into the back of another vehicle (in front of him) as he did not stop soon enough. He did not watch the car in front of him. The police were there. I wonder who got the ticket? heh heh
          (No injuries. Some damage to both vehicles.)

        3. it must have been magnussen ..
          He often does that ;)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

All comments are moderated. See the Comment Policy and FAQ for more.
If the person you're replying to is a registered user you can notify them of your reply using '@username'.